Financial System Infrastructure in Brazil Customer Challenges and Pains Analysis¶
Challenges and Pains faced by Customers¶
Customers within the Brazilian Financial System Infrastructure (FSI) face a range of challenges and pains, impacting both Business-to-Business (B2B) and Business-to-Consumer (B2C) segments. These issues stem from various aspects of the value chain, including infrastructure limitations, market structure, regulatory complexities, and technological gaps.
A primary pain point for both individuals and businesses is the high cost of financial services. This is evident in elevated Merchant Discount Rates (MDRs) for businesses accepting card payments, significant custody fees for asset owners, and brokerage spreads in investment activities. The overall "Custo Brasil," encompassing high taxes and operational expenses, contributes significantly to these costs, making financial transactions more expensive compared to other markets. Concentration risk in certain FSI segments, such as exchange, clearing, and custody, can also limit price competition and potentially inflate fees.
Security and fraud represent a critical challenge and a major pain point for all customer segments. With the rapid growth of digital payments like Pix, there has been a corresponding rise in fraudulent activities, leading to financial losses and erosion of trust. Ransomware attacks targeting core banking systems highlight the vulnerability of the underlying infrastructure. Ensuring robust cybersecurity measures and effective fraud prevention and dispute resolution mechanisms is paramount but remains a constant struggle for financial institutions and impacts customer confidence.
Limited access to appropriate financial solutions and financial inclusion gaps particularly affect Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) and Individual Micro-entrepreneurs (MEIs). While large corporations are generally well-served by traditional banking, SMEs often find existing solutions inadequate for their specific needs, including efficient payment processing, access to affordable credit, and tools for managing receivables and payables. MEIs require even more accessible and low-cost basic financial services. In the B2C segment, while financial inclusion has increased significantly, there is a pain point for retail investors seeking better access to diverse investment options beyond traditional low-yield products, requiring more sophisticated tools, advice, and comparison platforms.
Operational inefficiencies and a lack of speed persist due to various factors within the infrastructure. Legacy core systems within some financial institutions can hinder the adoption of modern standards like ISO 20022 and the implementation of real-time capabilities across all services. Interoperability gaps between different systems, such as disparate registry schemas and proprietary exchange APIs, complicate straight-through processing and can lead to delays and increased operational complexity for businesses. The process of registering assets and perfecting liens can also be slowed down by fragmented identifiers and complex procedures.
Complexity and a lack of transparency in financial processes and fee structures can be a source of pain for customers. Navigating the regulatory landscape is challenging even for institutions, which can indirectly impact customer experience. Understanding the breakdown of costs in services like payments (e.g., MDR components) or the specifics of asset registration and custody can be difficult. Resolving disputes, such as those related to chargebacks or Pix fraud, can also be a complex and burdensome process for customers.
Finally, while initiatives like Open Finance are addressing this, interoperability issues and data siloing have historically limited the ability of customers to have a unified view of their finances or seamlessly share their data to access more personalized and competitive products and services. The complexity of data governance, including ensuring quality, consent, and ethical use in these new ecosystems, also presents challenges related to privacy and trust for customers.
Here is a prioritized table of the main challenges and pains faced by customers:
| Priority | Challenge/Pain | Description | Customer Segment(s) Primarily Affected |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | High Costs of Financial Services | Elevated transaction fees (MDRs, brokerage, custody), impacting profitability for businesses and returns for investors; overall Custo Brasil. | B2B, B2C |
| 2 | Security Threats and Fraud | Financial losses and loss of trust due to cyberattacks and fraud, particularly in digital payments like Pix. | B2B, B2C |
| 3 | Limited Access to Appropriate Solutions / Inclusion Gaps | Underserved needs of SMEs and MEIs; lack of accessible and diverse investment options and tools for retail investors. | B2B, B2C |
| 4 | Operational Inefficiencies and Lack of Speed | Delays and complexity caused by legacy systems, interoperability gaps, and cumbersome processes in transactions and asset management. | B2B, B2C |
| 5 | Complexity and Lack of Transparency | Difficulty in understanding costs, processes, and regulations; burdensome dispute resolution. | B2B, B2C |
| 6 | Interoperability Issues and Data Siloing (Historical/Ongoing) | Difficulty in integrating financial data and services across different platforms and institutions (being addressed by Open Finance). | B2B, B2C |
Correlation with Value Chain¶
The challenges and pains faced by customers in the Brazilian FSI are closely correlated with specific stages and characteristics of the value chain:
- High Costs: This pain is significantly influenced by multiple value chain stages. Payments Processing contributes through MDRs and processing fees. Trading & Execution, Clearing, Custody & Asset Servicing, and Registry layers contribute through various transaction, safekeeping, and registration fees. The market structure, particularly Concentration Risk in areas like exchange, clearing, and custody (Value Chain Bottlenecks), allows dominant players to potentially charge higher fees. Compliance costs arising from Regulation & Supervision can also be passed down to customers.
- Security and Fraud: This pain directly relates to the effectiveness of Risk Management frameworks and the robustness of the Technology & Innovation infrastructure. Weaknesses in fraud detection and prevention systems within Payments Processing, particularly for widely adopted methods like Pix, directly expose customers to financial losses. Cybersecurity vulnerabilities in core systems across the value chain represent a systemic risk that impacts customer trust and security.
- Limited Access to Appropriate Solutions / Inclusion Gaps: This pain is linked to how services are structured and delivered across the chain. In Origination & Structuring, smaller businesses may lack access to capital markets for funding. In Payments Processing, the availability and affordability of solutions for SMEs and MEIs are crucial. The evolution of Technology & Innovation, particularly through fintechs and digital banks, is attempting to fill these gaps by offering more accessible and tailored services. The development of the Registry infrastructure for receivables is important for improving SME access to credit.
- Operational Inefficiencies and Lack of Speed: These issues are tied to the technological and process maturity of various value chain stages. Legacy Core Systems in Technology & Innovation directly impede efficiency. Interoperability Gaps across Trading & Execution, Clearing, Settlement, and Registry slow down processes and increase complexity. The efficiency of Settlement finality is also critical for managing risk and enabling faster transactions.
- Complexity and Lack of Transparency: This pain point is partly a function of the intricate nature of the financial system and its Regulation & Supervision. The various Commercial Relationships and fee structures across different intermediaries can be difficult for customers to understand. Challenges in Dispute Resolution, often stemming from issues in Payments Processing, add to customer frustration and the perception of a lack of transparency.
- Interoperability Issues and Data Siloing: These are directly related to the standards and connectivity within the Technology & Innovation layer and across various functional stages like Registry and Payments Processing. The Open Finance initiative aims to improve this by mandating data sharing and interoperability, but the historical pain of data silos has limited integrated financial management for customers.
References¶
ANBIMA. Brasil tem R$ 9 trilhões em ativos custodiados. https://www.anbima.com.br/pt_br/noticias/brasil-tem-r-9-trilhoes-em-ativos-custodiados.html ANBIMA Data. Volume emitido de incentivadas supera em 65 % o total de 2023. https://data.anbima.com.br/debentures/volume-emitido-debentures-incentivadas-supera-2023 Banco Central do Brasil. Infraestruturas do Mercado Financeiro. https://www.bcb.gov.br/estabilidadefinanceira/infraestruturasmercado Banco Central do Brasil. Sistema de Pagamentos Brasileiro (SPB). https://www.bcb.gov.br/estabilidadefinanceira/sistemadepagamentosbrasileiro Banco Central do Brasil. Sistema Especial de Liquidação e de Custódia (Selic). https://www.bcb.gov.br/estabilidadefinanceira/selic CERC. Infraestruturas do Mercado Financeiro (IMF). https://cerc.inf.br/sobre-imf/ Conjur. Infraestruturas de mercado financeiro: invisíveis, mas essenciais. https://www.conjur.com.br/2024-jul-10/infraestruturas-de-mercado-financeiro-invisiveis-mas-essenciais/ Dock. Pagamentos instantâneos: principais sistemas na LatAm e no mundo. https://www.dock.tech/blog/pagamentos-instantaneos-principais-sistemas/ FEBRABAN. Pix é o meio de pagamento mais usado no Brasil em 2023. https://quantoplan.febraban.org.br/noticias/pix-e-o-meio-de-pagamento-mais-usado-no-brasil-em-2023-ted-lidera-em-valores-transacionados Finsiders Brasil. Quantidade de pagamentos digitais cresce 31 % no primeiro semestre. https://www.finsiders.com.br/noticias/pagamentos/quantidade-de-pagamentos-digitais-cresce-31-no-primeiro-semestre-do-ano/ IT Forum. Tendências de tecnologia para o mercado financeiro. https://itforum.com.br/tendencias-de-tecnologia-para-o-mercado-financeiro/ Instituto Propague. Pix eleva movimentação via iniciação de pagamento a nível recorde. https://institutopropague.org/noticias/pix-eleva-movimentacao-via-iniciacao-de-pagamento-a-nivel-recorde/ JOTA. Os 9 anos do marco legal e regulatório de registradoras e depositários centrais. https://www.jota.info/opiniao-e-analise/artigos/os-9-anos-do-marco-legal-e-regulatorio-de-registradoras-e-depositarios-centrais-08062022 Matera. SPB: o que você precisa saber sobre o Sistema de Pagamentos Brasileiro. https://blog.matera.com/sistema-de-pagamentos-brasileiro-spb/ Money Times. B3 (B3SA3): Volume financeiro médio diário cresce 4,1 % em abril. https://www.moneytimes.com.br/b3-b3sa3-volume-financeiro-medio-diario-cresce-41-em-abril-para-r-256-bilhoes/ Nuclea RI. Núclea, antiga CIP, entra para associação da criptoeconomia. https://ri.nuclea.com.br/noticias/nuclea-antiga-cip-entra-para-associacao-da-criptoeconomia/