Skip to content

Value Chain Analysis of the Insurance in Brazil.

Commercial Relationships:

The insurance value chain in Brazil involves a complex web of commercial relationships between various players, extending beyond the direct insurer-customer link. These relationships are fundamental to the industry's operation, enabling risk transfer, product distribution, operational efficiency, and financial management.

At the initial Product Development & Underwriting stage, Insurance Companies (Seguradoras) are the central players, designing insurance products. They often engage in commercial relationships with Reinsurance Companies (Resseguradoras). Insurers transfer a portion of their risk exposure to reinsurers through contractual agreements, paying reinsurance premiums in exchange for coverage against large or catastrophic losses. This relationship is crucial for insurers to manage their solvency and underwrite risks that would otherwise be too large for their balance sheet. Commercial terms involve negotiated premium rates and contract clauses defining the scope of coverage and triggers for reinsurance activation. Insurers also engage with Actuaries and Specialized Consulting Firms on a fee-for-service or project basis to obtain technical expertise for risk modeling, product pricing, and regulatory compliance. These consultants are paid for their specialized analysis and recommendations, forming a business-to-business (B2B) service relationship.

In the Marketing & Distribution phase, commercial relationships are primarily focused on reaching and acquiring customers. Insurance Companies utilize multiple channels, each involving distinct commercial arrangements. A significant channel is the relationship with Insurance Brokers (Corretores de Seguros). Insurers pay brokers commissions on the premiums of policies sold. This is a performance-based commercial relationship where brokers act as independent intermediaries representing the client's interests and finding suitable policies from various insurers. Companies like Tokio Marine Seguradora work extensively with brokers. Bradesco Seguros is actively increasing its engagement with market brokers. This relationship is governed by commission structures that vary by product type and insurer, incentivizing brokers based on sales volume and sometimes profitability of the business brought in. Another major channel is Bancassurance, where banks distribute insurance products. This involves a strategic partnership between an Insurance Company (often a subsidiary or partner of the bank) and the Bank. The bank provides access to its vast customer base and branch network. Commercial terms usually involve the bank receiving a share of the premium or commissions for policies sold through its channels. Examples include CAIXA Seguridade leveraging Caixa Econômica Federal's network and client base, Itaú Seguros utilizing Itaú Unibanco's infrastructure, and BB Seguridade partnered with Banco do Brasil. This is typically a long-term, often exclusive, distribution agreement. Digital Platforms, including insurtechs, online brokers, and comparison websites, represent another growing distribution channel. Insurers form commercial partnerships with these platforms, paying referral fees, commissions, or advertising costs for lead generation and policy sales facilitated through the platform. Porto Seguro, for instance, utilizes its app for customer interaction and likely sales facilitation. Affinity Groups, such as retailers or associations, partner with insurers to offer insurance products embedded within the purchase of goods or services or exclusively to their members. The commercial relationship involves the affinity partner receiving a commission or revenue share for distributing the insurance product.

For Policy Administration & Customer Service, Insurance Companies primarily handle these functions internally. However, they may outsource specific tasks to Third-Party Administrators (TPAs) or contract with Technology Providers for software solutions. Commercial relationships with TPAs involve service agreements where the insurer pays the TPA a fee based on the volume of policies managed or services provided. Technology providers are paid licensing fees or service fees for the use of their software platforms.

In Claims Management, when an insured event occurs, the relationship shifts. Insurance Companies interact with policyholders, Loss Adjusters, and Service Providers. Loss Adjusters are independent professionals contracted by insurers to assess the damages and circumstances of a claim. Insurers pay adjusters a fee for their services, which might be fixed, hourly, or based on a percentage of the claim amount. Service Providers, such as auto repair shops, hospitals, or construction companies, are involved in resolving the claim. Insurers have commercial agreements with preferred networks of service providers, paying them directly for the services rendered to the policyholder (e.g., car repairs, medical treatment). In cases of large claims, the Reinsurance Company becomes involved, paying the insurer for the portion of the claim covered by the reinsurance treaty. This payment relationship is defined by the terms of the reinsurance contract. Itaú Seguros demonstrated this relationship by taking action to support clients affected by climate events, which can lead to large claim volumes potentially involving reinsurers.

Finally, in Investment Management, Insurance Companies hold significant reserves. They may manage these funds internally or engage External Asset Management Firms. The relationship with asset managers is a B2B service agreement where the insurer pays management fees based on the value of the assets under management or performance fees. Insurers belonging to large financial conglomerates, like Bradesco, Itaú, and BB Seguridade, often leverage the investment management capabilities of their parent bank, creating an internal commercial relationship or integrated financial structure where profits are shared.

Products and Services Exchanged:

Along the insurance value chain, a variety of products and services are exchanged between the different players.

In the Product Development & Underwriting stage, the primary products exchanged are the insurance policy contracts themselves. Insurance Companies develop and offer these contracts for various segments: Life (Vida), Health (Saúde), Property and Casualty (Seguros Patrimoniais e de Responsabilidade Civil), Auto (Seguro Automóvel), Rural (Seguro Rural), among others. These contracts represent a promise from the insurer to the policyholder to provide financial compensation or services upon the occurrence of a specified insured event, in exchange for premium payments. Reinsurance Companies exchange reinsurance coverage with insurers, essentially selling protection against large losses on the portfolio of risks the insurer has underwritten. Actuaries and Consulting Firms provide specialized services such as risk assessment models, pricing analysis, product design consultation, and regulatory compliance guidance.

During Marketing & Distribution, the main product flowing from the insurer to the customer (via intermediaries) is the insurance policy. The intermediary (broker, bank branch, digital platform) provides distribution services and sales services to the insurer, presenting the insurance product to potential clients. Brokers provide advisory services to clients, helping them understand their needs and comparing different insurance offerings. Digital platforms provide comparison services and an online marketplace for insurance products. In return for facilitating sales, intermediaries receive commissions or fees from the insurer.

In Policy Administration & Customer Service, the insurer exchanges policy documents with the policyholder. They provide administrative services related to managing the policy lifecycle, including premium collection services, renewal services, endorsement processing, and cancellation processing. Insurers offer customer support services through various channels (phone, email, chat, branches), providing information, answering queries, and handling complaints. CAIXA Seguridade focused on reducing complaints, highlighting the importance of these customer service interactions. TPAs, if used, provide these administrative and customer service functions to the insurer on an outsourced basis. Technology Providers exchange software licenses and maintenance services for policy management systems.

The Claims Management stage involves several exchanges. Policyholders provide claim notifications and supporting documentation to the insurer. The insurer provides claim processing services, including verification, investigation, and assessment. Loss Adjusters provide damage assessment services and investigation reports to the insurer. Service Providers (repair shops, hospitals, etc.) exchange repair services, medical services, or other relevant restoration services with the policyholder (or the insurer on behalf of the policyholder). The insurer provides claim payment to the policyholder or directly to service providers. In large claims, the Reinsurance Company provides reimbursement or claim payment to the insurer based on the reinsurance contract. BB Seguridade's performance in rural insurance claims management impacts the loss ratio, a key metric in this stage. Itaú Seguros provided support services to clients affected by climate events.

Finally, in Investment Management, the insurance company's accumulated reserves (financial capital) are exchanged for various financial assets, such as bonds, equities, and real estate, through transactions in financial markets or with asset management firms. Asset Management Firms provide portfolio management services and investment advisory services to the insurer. The return generated from these investments (e.g., interest, dividends, capital gains) flows back to the insurer, representing investment income.

Business Models:

The commercial relationships in the Brazilian insurance value chain are underpinned by various business models employed by the players to generate revenue and create value.

Insurance Companies operate based on a core risk pooling and transfer business model. They collect premiums from a large number of policyholders, creating a pool of funds. They then use statistical analysis (underwriting) to assess and price the risk of future claims. The core revenue comes from premiums, and profitability is derived from managing claims effectively and generating investment income. Companies like Bradesco Seguros, Porto Seguro, MAPFRE, and Tokio Marine operate under this fundamental model, differentiating themselves through product focus, service quality, and distribution strategies.

Within this, various distribution business models are prevalent: The Brokerage Model involves independent brokers acting as intermediaries. Their business model is based on earning commissions from insurance companies for policies sold. They add value by providing expertise, comparing options for clients, and handling sales and administrative tasks. Insurers benefit from accessing the broker's client base and sales force without the direct costs of employing their own. This model is strong for complex products and corporate clients, but also widely used for personal lines, as seen with Tokio Marine and Bradesco Seguros working with thousands of brokers. The Bancassurance Model is a partnership-driven distribution model where banks leverage their branch network and customer relationships to sell insurance products. The bank acts as a distribution channel, earning commission or a revenue share. This model is highly effective for reaching a large number of clients, particularly for simpler, mass-market products like life insurance, simple P&C, and capitalization products. CAIXA Seguridade, Itaú Seguros, and BB Seguridade are prime examples of players heavily reliant on this model due to their integration with major banks. The Direct Sales Model involves the insurer selling directly to customers without intermediaries, typically through their own sales force, call centers, or websites. This model allows insurers to control the customer relationship directly and potentially reduce distribution costs, although it requires significant investment in sales infrastructure. The Digital Platform Model involves using online channels (websites, apps) for marketing, sales, and service. Insurtechs often operate primarily on this model, offering convenience, transparency, and sometimes innovative product features. Porto Seguro's use of its app for customer interaction and services aligns with incorporating digital channels into their broader model.

Reinsurance Companies operate on a risk-transfer business model. They assume a portion of the risks underwritten by primary insurers in exchange for a share of the premium. Their profitability comes from managing the portfolio of risks assumed and generating investment income from the premiums received before claims are paid.

Service Providers like repair shops and hospitals operate on a standard fee-for-service model, providing their core services and being paid by the insurer (or sometimes the policyholder who is then reimbursed) for the services related to a claim.

Asset Management Firms operate on an asset management fee model, charging clients (insurers in this case) a fee, typically a percentage of the assets under management, for their investment management services.

Beyond these specific models, the industry as a whole relies on a regulatory compliance model, adhering to rules set by SUSEP, which govern everything from product design and pricing to solvency requirements and claims handling.

Increasingly, insurers are adopting business models that focus on customer experience and operational efficiency, leveraging technology to streamline processes in policy administration and claims management. Porto Seguro's emphasis on customer experience and digital tools is an example. CAIXA Seguridade's focus on reducing complaints also points to efforts in improving service.

Bottlenecks and Challenges:

Despite significant growth and innovation, the Brazilian insurance value chain faces several bottlenecks and challenges that can impact efficiency, profitability, and customer satisfaction.

One significant challenge lies in Customer Service and Complaint Management. The high volume of interactions in Policy Administration and Claims Management can lead to bottlenecks if systems and processes are inefficient. The focus by CAIXA Seguridade on reducing complaints registered with BACEN suggests that managing customer satisfaction and resolving issues effectively is a key challenge for insurers in Brazil. Complex policy language, slow claims processing, and inadequate communication can contribute to customer dissatisfaction and regulatory scrutiny.

Claims Management Efficiency and Fraud Prevention represent another critical area. Investigating claims, assessing damages accurately, and making timely payments require robust processes and skilled personnel. The mention of detecting and preventing fraudulent claims highlights the ongoing challenge of combating insurance fraud, which can significantly impact insurers' profitability and contribute to higher premiums for honest policyholders. While BB Seguridade reported a record-low loss ratio in rural insurance, indicating effective risk management and claims handling in that specific segment, loss ratios can be volatile and represent a constant challenge, particularly in segments prone to frequent or large claims like auto and health. Climate events, as mentioned in the context of Itaú Seguros supporting affected clients, pose an increasing challenge, leading to surges in claims that test insurers' capacity and financial resilience.

Distribution Channel Management presents both opportunities and challenges. While multiple channels like brokers, bancassurance, and digital platforms expand reach, managing these diverse channels effectively can be complex. Ensuring consistent product knowledge among intermediaries, managing commission structures fairly, and integrating different sales processes are ongoing challenges. The reliance on specific channels, like bancassurance for CAIXA Seguridade, BB Seguridade, and Itaú Seguros, while providing access to a large client base, can also create dependence on the partner bank's priorities and operational efficiency. Brokers, while independent, require strong relationship management and support from insurers to be effective.

Regulatory Compliance and Adapting to Changes imposed by SUSEP are constant challenges. The regulatory environment is dynamic, requiring insurers to continuously adapt their products, processes, and capital management to remain compliant. Obtaining necessary approvals for new products in the Product Development phase can also be a bottleneck.

Digital Transformation and Technology Adoption are ongoing challenges. While digital platforms are increasingly used for distribution and customer interaction (Porto Seguro's app usage), fully integrating technology across all value chain steps, from underwriting to claims payment, requires significant investment and expertise. Legacy systems can be a bottleneck to implementing more efficient digital processes.

Finally, Market Competition and Pricing Pressures are inherent challenges. With multiple players competing across segments, maintaining profitability requires accurate pricing (underwriting), efficient operations, and effective investment management. The need to balance competitive pricing with maintaining sufficient reserves and profitability is a continuous act.

References: