Value Chain Analysis of the Food Processing in Brazil.

Commercial Relationships

The Brazilian food processing value chain is characterized by a complex web of commercial relationships that connect agricultural producers, food processors, distributors, and retailers or food service providers. These relationships vary in formality and structure, reflecting the diverse nature of the industry and the players involved.

At the initial stage, Agricultural Production, the primary commercial relationships are between farmers (including large-scale commercial farms, small and medium-sized farms, and agricultural cooperatives) and the food processing industry or intermediaries. Large-scale commercial farms often engage in direct sales to large processing companies through established contracts. These contracts can be long-term agreements that specify volume, quality standards, delivery schedules, and pricing mechanisms. This provides a degree of stability for both parties, ensuring a consistent supply of raw materials for processors and a guaranteed market for farmers. Small and medium-sized farms may interact with processors through cooperatives or intermediaries. Cooperatives play a significant role, aggregating the production of numerous smallholders, enhancing their bargaining power, and facilitating access to processing and distribution channels. Spot market transactions also occur, particularly for certain commodities, where prices are determined by immediate supply and demand conditions. Integrated producers, involved in both farming and processing, represent a vertically integrated model where the commercial relationship is internal to the company.

In the Processing/Agroindustry stage, the main commercial relationships are with agricultural producers (as described above) and with the distribution sector. Processors purchase raw materials through contracts, cooperatives, or spot markets. They then sell their finished food and beverage products to various distributors. These relationships can involve large volume transactions with major wholesale companies and retail chains. Processors negotiate terms related to price, payment, volume, product specifications, and logistics. For smaller processors, relationships might be with independent distributors or direct sales to local retailers and food service establishments. The relationships with large distributors and retailers are often characterized by strong negotiation dynamics due to the market power held by these large buyers.

The Distribution stage involves the movement of processed foods from processors to the final points of sale. Wholesalers purchase in bulk from processors and sell to retailers, smaller distributors, and food service providers. Their relationships are primarily B2B (business-to-business), focusing on volume, logistics efficiency, and price margins. Retail chains have direct commercial relationships with both processors and wholesalers, depending on the scale and type of product. They negotiate purchasing agreements, shelf space allocation, promotional activities, and logistics for stocking their stores. Food service distributors similarly procure products from processors and wholesalers to supply restaurants, hotels, and institutions. Independent distributors often serve niche markets or specific geographic areas, maintaining relationships with a range of processors and smaller retail or food service clients.

Finally, the Retail/Food Service stage involves selling processed food products to the end consumer. Retailers (supermarkets, hypermarkets, grocery stores, etc.) have a direct commercial relationship with consumers, involving transactions at the point of sale. This relationship is largely B2C (business-to-consumer) and focuses on product availability, pricing, variety, quality, and the overall shopping experience. Food service establishments purchase from distributors or directly from processors (especially for specialized ingredients or bulk products) and sell prepared food and beverages to consumers. Their commercial relationship with consumers is based on the dining experience, quality of food, service, and price. E-commerce is an increasingly important channel in both retail and food service, establishing digital commercial relationships with consumers.

Across the value chain, especially between processing and distribution/retail, power dynamics can significantly influence commercial relationships. Large processing companies and major retail chains often hold considerable leverage in negotiations due to their scale and market share. Contract farming is a notable commercial relationship model in the agricultural production stage, providing structure and reducing market risk for certain commodities.

Products and Services Exchanged

Along the Brazilian food processing value chain, a wide array of products and services are exchanged at each step:

In Agricultural Production, the primary products exchanged are raw agricultural commodities. This includes a vast range of items such as grains (soybeans, corn, wheat), oilseeds, fruits, vegetables, live animals (cattle, poultry, pigs), raw milk, and eggs. The services exchanged at this stage can include transportation of produce to initial aggregation points or directly to processors, sorting, initial cleaning, and sometimes basic packaging for transport. Agricultural cooperatives also provide services to their members, such as technical assistance, access to inputs, storage, and collective bargaining for sales.

Moving to the Processing/Agroindustry stage, the raw materials are transformed into a multitude of processed food and beverage products. The products exchanged here are diverse and include:

• Meat Products: Fresh cuts of beef, poultry, and pork; processed meats like sausages, ham, and cold cuts; frozen meat products.
• Dairy Products: Pasteurized milk, cheese, yogurt, butter, milk powder, and other dairy derivatives.
• Grain-Based Products: Flours, स्टार्चes, oils, animal feed, pasta, bread, and baked goods.
• Fruit and Vegetable Products: Juices, canned fruits and vegetables, frozen fruits and vegetables, purees, jams, and dried fruits.
• Other Processed Foods: Confectionery, snacks, ready-to-eat meals, sauces, soups, baby food, and various food ingredients and additives.
• Beverages: Soft drinks, juices, bottled water, beer, wine, and spirits.

Services exchanged at this stage include contract manufacturing (processing raw materials provided by another company), co-packing (packaging products for other companies), quality control and food safety testing, research and development for new products, and branding and marketing services for the finished goods.

In the Distribution stage, the products exchanged are the finished, packaged food and beverage items from the processing stage. Distributors handle large volumes of these products, moving them through warehouses and transportation networks. Services provided by distributors include warehousing and storage (often temperature-controlled for perishable goods), inventory management, order picking and fulfillment, transportation and logistics (including fleet management and route optimization), and sales and account management services to retailers and food service clients. Wholesalers provide the service of breaking down bulk shipments into smaller quantities suitable for retailers and food service providers.

At the Retail/Food Service stage, the products are the processed food and beverage items presented to the final consumer. In retail, this includes the full range of products available on supermarket shelves, in hypermarkets, convenience stores, and online platforms. In food service, the products are the ingredients and prepared meals served to customers in restaurants, hotels, and institutional settings. The services exchanged in retail include merchandising, customer service, operating physical stores and online platforms, and sometimes delivery services. In food service, services encompass food preparation, serving, and providing a dining experience.

Business Models

Various business models are employed throughout the Brazilian food processing value chain, reflecting the strategies adopted by different players to create and capture value.

In Agricultural Production, common business models include:

• Independent Producers: Farmers who operate their own farms and sell their produce to processors, cooperatives, or through intermediaries. Their business model focuses on efficient farming practices to maximize yield and quality.
• Agricultural Cooperatives: Member-owned organizations where farmers pool their resources for purchasing inputs, processing, and marketing. The business model centers on collective action to achieve economies of scale, improve bargaining power, and share resources and knowledge.
• Contract Farming: A model where farmers agree to produce specific commodities under terms agreed upon with a buyer, typically a processing company. The processor often provides inputs, technical assistance, and a guaranteed market at a predetermined price or pricing mechanism. This model reduces market risk for farmers but can create dependency on the contracting company.
• Integrated Production: Companies that own and operate farming operations alongside their processing facilities. This vertically integrated model allows for greater control over the supply chain, quality, and costs, but requires significant capital investment.

In the Processing/Agroindustry stage, key business models include:

• Large-Scale Industrial Processing: Large national and multinational companies operating high-capacity processing plants. Their business models focus on mass production, efficiency, economies of scale, brand building, and extensive distribution networks. Examples include major meat processors, dairy companies, and grain processors.
• Specialty and Niche Processing: Smaller and medium-sized companies focusing on specific product categories, value-added products, or niche markets (e.g., organic foods, gourmet products, regional specialties). Their business model emphasizes product differentiation, quality, and often direct relationships with retailers or food service providers.
• Cooperative Processing: Agricultural cooperatives that have invested in their own processing facilities to add value to their members' produce. Their business model combines agricultural production and processing, aiming to capture more value within the cooperative structure and benefit member farmers.
• Ingredient Suppliers: Companies specializing in processing agricultural raw materials into ingredients used by other food manufacturers (e.g., oils, flours, starches, flavors, additives). Their business model is B2B, focused on providing high-quality, consistent ingredients to food processors.

For the Distribution stage, prevalent business models include:

• Wholesale (Atacado): Companies that buy in large volumes from processors and sell to retailers and food service businesses. Their business model relies on efficient logistics, bulk sales, and competitive pricing to serve business customers. The "atacarejo" model, combining wholesale and retail, is also popular in Brazil, serving both businesses and end consumers.
• Retail Distribution Centers: Large retail chains operating their own distribution centers to manage the flow of products from processors and wholesalers to their stores. This integrated model allows for greater control over inventory and logistics.
• Food Service Distribution: Companies specialized in distributing food products to restaurants, hotels, and institutions. Their business model focuses on providing a wide range of products and reliable delivery services tailored to the needs of food service operators.
• Independent Distribution: Smaller distributors serving specific geographic areas or product categories. Their business model is often based on local market knowledge and personalized service.

Finally, in the Retail/Food Service stage, the main business models are:

• Supermarket and Hypermarket Chains: Large-scale retailers offering a wide variety of food and non-food products. Their business model focuses on high sales volumes, competitive pricing, diverse product offerings, and the shopping experience.
• Grocery Stores (Varejo de Proximidade): Smaller neighborhood stores offering convenience and personalized service. Their business model is based on serving local communities and building customer loyalty.
• Cash-and-Carry (Atacarejo): A hybrid model combining wholesale and retail, offering products in bulk and individual units at competitive prices, targeting both consumers and businesses. This model has seen significant growth in Brazil.
• Restaurants and Food Service Establishments: Businesses preparing and serving food for immediate consumption. Their business model focuses on culinary offerings, customer experience, location, and service.
• Online Retail and Food Delivery: E-commerce platforms and delivery services providing convenient access to processed foods and prepared meals. Their business model leverages technology and logistics to reach consumers directly at their homes or workplaces.

Bottlenecks and Challenges

Despite its significant size and importance to the Brazilian economy, the food processing value chain faces several key bottlenecks and challenges:

Logistical Infrastructure Deficiencies: A major challenge is the inadequate and inefficient logistics infrastructure, particularly transportation and storage. Brazil heavily relies on road transport, which is often affected by poor road conditions, increasing transportation costs and leading to delays. The long distances between major agricultural production areas (like the Midwest) and ports or processing centers exacerbate this issue. Storage capacity has not kept pace with the growth in agricultural production, leading to potential losses and hurried sales, especially for grains. Port and transport system bottlenecks also increase logistics costs and reduce competitiveness, particularly for exports.

High Costs: The industry faces high operational costs, including those related to transportation, energy, labor, and taxation. The cost of raw materials can also be volatile, impacting processing margins. High interest rates and currency volatility can hinder investment and growth.

Bureaucracy and Regulatory Issues: The Brazilian regulatory environment can be complex and bureaucratic. Obtaining approvals for new ingredients or products can be time-consuming. Recent proposed changes to meat inspection standards, potentially replacing federal inspectors with industry-hired technicians, raise concerns about maintaining food safety standards and could jeopardize export agreements. Overlapping institutional functions and distortions in regulatory frameworks in related sectors like energy also pose challenges.

Power Imbalances and Farmer Bargaining Power: In some segments, particularly in the relationship between farmers and large processing companies or input suppliers, there can be significant power imbalances. Individual farmers, especially smaller ones, may have limited bargaining capacity to negotiate prices for their produce or inputs, potentially trapping them in cycles of indebtedness. While cooperatives help address this to some extent, challenges remain.

Access to Credit and Financing: Limited access to affordable credit for farmers and related food sectors can dampen investment in productivity improvements and expansion.

Environmental Concerns and Sustainability Pressures: Increasing pressure to preserve the environment and comply with stricter environmental regulations can impact land development and infrastructure projects. The sustainability of the value chain, particularly regarding land use, deforestation, and the use of pesticides, is a significant concern with potential impacts on market access and reputation.

Market Concentration and Competition: While the industry is diverse, there is a degree of market concentration in certain segments, particularly in processing (e.g., meat, grains) and retail. This can affect competition and influence commercial relationships.

Food Safety and Quality Control: Maintaining consistent food safety and quality standards across the entire value chain, from farm to table, is crucial but can be challenging, especially with a large number of small and medium-sized players. Regulatory changes related to inspection services can exacerbate these concerns.

Formalization Challenges for Small Producers and Processors: The process of formalizing small family agro-industries can be difficult due to complex sanitary, environmental, and tax regulations, potentially excluding some producers from formal markets.

Changing Consumer Demands: Evolving consumer preferences towards healthier, more sustainable, and convenient food products require the industry to adapt and innovate, which can be a challenge for smaller or less agile players.

These bottlenecks and challenges highlight the need for continued investment in infrastructure, regulatory streamlining, initiatives to support smaller producers, and a focus on sustainability and food safety to ensure the continued growth and competitiveness of the Brazilian food processing industry.

References

1. FINAL TRANSFER Food Processing Report Brazil - Agroberichten Buitenland. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJuTq6n_sBIyRpA24yj5QQu_NMsSq8D_zNkbPADyuAHBlglU9sFATZnsNk041DoE7Tqw-S05tixJ2UpGsHpH_3juZFlqOmkPmGOdpXVFCIOLTycqD9FqLvf56tYj-rovt6UBK_TO0907BnCBNVlNe-WGf-KV6qgEimKuSKGv6s83vglzyNCqo3Xzo8fWCMC16Z0JvNYc-NyiZeNBwCbDslWoWrUERzVCyQD0xcl-lUhksjMtVrIVNmsliRNcT1wUt_R0tKnddApwQM9NYR8A6OfowFn2QTuXPSJwFL95VFLRJLeLNTNmFS1nZfe3I2_xiN8lWAJuTNlhk0RuBX3
2. Brazil's Momentum as a Global Agricultural Supplier Faces Headwinds - ers.usda.gov. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAIF8V09y70ARb4xNTWYfxGtBgsnMYBF7Dap3bBR29sYZj2Yg3VP2GFQViW2fwWz91XuMrIabGusbcAQ4xcrrSneE3La-6lMO4OaG_gHZ-TgcAW7dCenEjrXjtMHrPKs7xEKIYtL2Yj3Go_9ctmgQwHYPjXY8xgIIfNZtCwNE-axVmpgCRQm9HjkEcBfDGAMnRa1ytFies4zhdTHkiitDnUBRrSn3J1owE9xhC0DWQ==
3. Report Name: Retail Foods Annual - USDA Foreign Agricultural Service. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAKnSO-NWcx2FmGmriSedSP7RsvN2s5emO1hz-mzOHUzXE0cWWqJulD44G07KwVj2LRK0pUugUDbhOqsOVw3_8eScnHa-7ep3EW65yLQWsUWgBXoT_wTQa7e_tBgbjBaaoiN_k7zcQYGqCs7xcvL7A5U-4s859rxZsc1y9ABlJ5eU149oPXplFBvOKRZc02ja_zJTH06O8lPcYyLufIWam9-fOsjzYRssRoT8fk8E_wPUyfcudIFn575-VIgi45DeP17SW502dCpM-c=
4. The New Brazilian Law on Contract Farming. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJJdL1_x1v487hLAYvX15w6lnUVP38Ts3_AxyflG-swCcPgCNSkbNKc0pAnlOEan0W4IdgWhK1nxFyyGX8qsJANLEdXgK8BXyVoqMnQlw9f6HNsC1od7TMo88WI_Og8iZ_MkWSVtq2fA2GA4HzW2I24pO3ItKVKuUOuDoU2-V2Ww23MiNAC_9pVDCqSr2zJOIYY8Bt0wxSVZJFRnzvSiESHgsJP9MUyYGrE_yiufPrzaR8NBG-1mdcozruu_Es=
5. Brazil's Meat Inspection Standards at Risk Due to Regulatory Changes - iGrow News. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAIPL06R-ahFy4XndKBr3IlZz867fWxrwsjHWZaD_Dy4aswbcysuJOhroETKlHfbENoDEGFpuG8eZ9BU611ZBwa1k_9Me5wIaUjmW75EhzfS8tqZXJN9rWtxCPQFpnico3JXH7udpwpdsdtZF4MWscnBJxlz8Gj1aeJ1hB_rV2Y47KPEwOlt5xY6INUaMloaJxo=
6. Inclusive business models - FAO Knowledge Repository. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAKBt5TkrmUkBtzX2BdgBn2lJBnirrMqwdZzQ0rhHF-K9cHgPMcrnGsyoSIn-mzmyl6V_VEVgx7SKXokhE3Qr-1iJi3Fk8CML5lzUg3e3135QUAuOLo2yVu2U4R98lvo52mBT8yik6hpQmjgyIfmFHRg00ms_QLOCY7HOMJ7Yo9tiXi6s2zprZkdyZCI4L3-R7hqB5yjm7QDgEZDAg==
7. Report Name: Food Processing Ingredients Annual - USDA Foreign Agricultural Service. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqALZepFqTaGSnK-3kf9f2Hq0OwATjYkglUcfj9CWf3eV154dWbQH6dxb3SzkUQmooFNYK12TifrM2TJ7QAgW75dpX8CKyyDABxGPBSk0GcJGJt6AKHxh752tP8PS8koVH10qz1jU7au1rSbujcvF0D36TiZiN3XqHFLj-Eh25KpYj1X-ivfrHQqybVIvk4qNmoU30jqSBc87_wEYS6GqtdHLOBYwC6ACq-tUuiVmBQI1hsAIB5Rye2Hpzv5qieV3XJSgqZXHlSuk5APl9EUZk24fhFyXNsM2
8. Brazil Agribusiness – Challenges and Opportunities. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqALNOkrJ-vGRrJCqqGn1ffCHLey_1z8TANu30ovhCs96uL1-5m50R2UE6BVxUsmzIciMNGaEw0LGObjH6UMFp4sZMtkZxxERv1uyoOcyoND6DCPfXObit36gS1DgxtqzGJgiucGA9dJJUAPW6OPBJoBBFP67YFxG0xpCQ6cW66oi_EGlLfhPsSH997es0UOa
9. Transition to a sustainable food supply chain during disruptions: A study on the Brazilian food companies in the Covid-19 era - PMC - PubMed Central. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqALspc_Ncy_9X_cd1qCm313k65EMXbIdaWKqalVsh9xyOPivUghybR4oL7sG4KaGYfSKgOKG7PzM70Ha7ya9CXHoMrexoueEa-QC7o-_T_8krn2nPHJzfnfXxAqkIaw_0urcwU0iBK0n
10. Navigating the changing food landscape: exporting food to Brazil - - Promar International. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAK16JTDRQkPJ_AxLpHwT9j-5bbeQ1r2kVIXWvTSHbjVooCz_IVsuKmCFCzu_z6j9Lgi8d0pqswm1Avu9CKqGEOCzHqnzsbOGJvWRPKWquRijADxen_cjV0i8YRdLgQvz-PcZ1RJbUVGJVqonH12K2gC__K8iYaVdt-i7O5NHvc=
11. Report Name: Retail Foods - USDA Foreign Agricultural Service. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAIXSfVGfs3mAzmESpMTzozDtfd7NxwbpYeme_yVKMv6c8k6hiy3YoAElbJmhxe8Mj6eGI-WSP_d_TWB7djjfqI-c9Zd5Tvzqc4fTwYrxAHvgLUACTi9mkJskjsJrXOUCZ9c_6eZwpuD5VRCiP-RBvbfGPK973eIr1JOxIgBaZ6nUM5q96y0qvN2zbuHXcNSHCgNj7lWHmfcLbxvdaPoojR4SzDS5bmsVppnLKu3DmbYv8SRxYffBVfY7wpNWg==
12. Brazil Frozen Food Market Size, Share & Forecast - Astute Analytica. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqALGj2briK0wmZJjIJcXPFFgLfp21Tolu2U8RS5lYLxi9SIpC4DtQwnJAFJJPTHBWKIQfHNoD5puXA2ndGSLILfNVQId5EvXZFCHfsG_cJtZT9DLUCuA5HclTlrl7Ctv5dRmbxtHougb-gvfzV1gEMQEEn-F5O0lt_HWXAnTnI2Z
13. Production and Protection: A First Look at Key Challenges in Brazil - Climate Policy Initiative. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAIBqGcpz0Y4hyGiIa7dzc3GJ4FMNeZtXnz0g-3ILyHuD9prmFbjr3QQOGVO9mQLWpKqLb1NfciahvN4uZRaeQT_cjLa0H-9xgJfIBxew59DN8XTIYm6wIcr0RjsnWLtT55nMaLmPy9UPHA7YpuY6WNizcVy3AQ4GfIKsbW0ehntDHYRQIhUB2XetkD-Gzr62yBm8WD13LEL9vwIxCYAkydVgAGdsJK7nyzG3GP1f0P3STvGMVVL_SuOOYV2ug==
14. Analyzing complexities in the Brazilian soybean supply chain: a systems thinking and modeling approach | Emerald Insight. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqALMDWIB7Fyj5_H0xvKhK2EixyI3X3YHVrAigmpGDZp5rMpA5SmQpmT513QIYTyvWlbBVTVfDs86ARYRjqhw0jJTMYEJvU-nGr2pQqkAnk4yijgXLSKZL74gIGohNRgk_mET7EZP9evc-ts_S_edJw_v5Q7_R1G_pebZEcyGmB8sysEL4yye4A==
15. Brazil's nutrition labeling regulation: Challenges ahead on the path to guaranteeing consumer's right to adequate information - Frontiers. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAIOIUkGKZ6lBy2g9Lz47fksNu7gc_yjZz166kbqFhAp7Vwvg9xgSHIH7eUYy7MWbDhJu4ox7d0nNRXprJ7R3naesudlavtYIVl07jGrGZEH7zhnFT1drMypEBz7EMyS5HaONvDTh3ApYwkIKcwnvPc0OcKl1sqaZwpNQFNinyZVrcGDKjRpkERCAjI_
16. Business models for sustainable food systems: a typology based on a literature review. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAKjYq0uVOjKV3g9Tg6O_cP0SRemxrI-LDo3gsqktmQ_HtF6kg2FDPwHjbvfdqpWgtZHAezZgJ-u0S4kj0HcBp2ncvnqGjnpnsMT8yRrmnLqU-YoocunezCXH2pl0ik7SczFJdvZ_LwQki0ufg5CsrLb2dafIhAUAxtjGFCoPLotexC4x16fQwA2carwHODj6sv6k-0wMqwqzRA-6JM=
17. Explaining the stickiness of supply chain relations in the Brazilian soybean trade - Research Collection. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJb4aVA02tBiVf76nh7Sce2sqZe5XCsV_A7dkZPomtPn0Ze6sgBUBKaLOWYXZaEvTThGatBfgTNY5DdvhltmN1ixLRVDMjWuhswYGEzwqnx1YZgou_J5rQF6uJDSNuVIxCUL7x0dv6ysvxW5zegUcGCMQsba8YKVJPjonydxgW9zUPxHqzxnZvtks9GIPJk_iVrZCTXxpDxGomh9yIGyNU=
18. Explaining the stickiness of supply chain relations in the Brazilian soybean trade | Conservation Biogeography Lab - Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAKgU6fFvztG_z1BlT6Oj8qc6ueqtLUqUmk10ThzVCu6386d3tTwhic7pmpnRZ7_q6u9zXBGYM5VDk9TGAqkj92MiTVVJ4FnXfWyWmUHSTcwDzZF_iVdR0IsUgfnbB5nq7D-OR1H9wxfgzsNg9Q3a_pBkpj4-bvS5uVGaaAMAgKpg7ow4wWF6q28eV1I_sFYu1o=
19. REORGANIZATION OF GLOBAL VALUE CHAINS: ARE THERE OPPORTUNITIES FOR BRAZIL? - Scioteca. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAL_udyeXruqKoOKuzM7gyuK7FmSSoAsLybYx9P8d-erW5nH7n6tdjOwWoP0YgPPGr-CQBDHfw1WXoLcNQROkPKGS8woQXG9VUZRc0ZUqhkhTVfpxXQda9IVNM3Dr7vdFZK4IcSSz3PgONH0hmzUVingAT0tD0UyuJLIC263Rov4ZAn7M8zywDBiYJndscfegY2z2jKHIGFZM0U6BJqgDdNBnpOTycbyduYMSUyifNybUL9VGb88h4efehi1kNTK_5YyvTviOfIBc4BgeGbSncpH_E66JAYh5EKzvuXrtsUDDIO3gw==
20. The Food Industry in Brazil - CORE. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAKhwPZzcTnK_EvQgOsse86sJYknRLXsgRsCMKF41bMJpymn-uVliOcgmKuhdQ2MkwZLcvqZjyXecS_jCwHSQHMLd9hvic5q-I7ynYwBwebbCG_CgIoLMRh5wll5YBK4BGo=
21. Classification and categorization of Brazilian agricultural startups (Agtechs) | Emerald Insight. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAI6YtLzn4jHs79aG1vucQ1-VH4JFQQGB9_m6sOgaeeNoiPLKk_YbOJhwNQB66KLdz4ZVIAjneOhSMhgjsES3MIJhBJNsiwOaYolCj6zVSbhVj9lTObc-GWwmTMPBhuA6nJ9HFtLKe80XHvyztoWY_8-PU4Q5Sr_-PzLbJ_dQ8BBKDm_gLwq
22. The regulatory framework of plant-based food in Brazil | International Bar Association. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJR-U8VtLvD8TYeEytZ1-p_HN2_Dk0LO_LiCZcphqE3tW6lmalz1-Ces5DGDCLzOBGFutPBhGYfzeDhcgLtwYtReC8rWB-mlEt2UqikGyahpG3Q_-AeIvwRuMW0GsVejNt67Lbj
23. The Soybean Trap: Challenges and Risks for Brazilian Producers - Frontiers. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAIn3ETPjPHBu4SGna4dYHD7wXhWo6cV2T_qXyDD84r5JXbtzQ2-iZTyzsUFs775Q9cXRYQxLYvCBuLkmeoibyI3iGPsFEuGYRwdytGdeJAu0OEQzlVEnRXDGpJQ7jyOYe-61TwiMuqx6-yL35YzpnN-d4Ujj1NOyOda2FrZbPtjOBKALjKNRgRN8QJJZeYwNt_miEFVwkcmERnK
24. PUBLIC FOOD PROCUREMENT FROM SMALLHOLDER FARMERS – THE BRAZILIAN EXPERIENCE - Global Child Nutrition Foundation. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAIx-j-6C-dN-lC5fsVNbfzVIc6PcSWgUnWXC6GZuX3iRoOvjahHqYiATvRf0ChiOMSsze-soQ0orMVD7zxN4L8cKtVfqcpMG0iQklQaXyknHspp1sgKjLTWHeNyQtPMAC-UyEwcBdaaM98di2o_-uRYWRbsaY143J3bmBvEpDshi579cSS3zuCjRkpgyn1gvEpA5D3HQ80PCTYs
25. Confronting the Crisis: Challenges in Brazil's Agricultural Input Distribution Post-Judicial Recoveries - AgroPages.com-agrochemical news. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJK2DydQyXa6K9qu_S2897Fzrbh-AWTW-n2bYcdMa9knY4vg-39T6UpxTbfax8SjyrYhIIb4F6-IR8n2TIxZefhJ_G7fedFIiBAaKmOJrzGZ7Q4gtam2jTsSuPp6TnpCkibKO2kUMXLTbZbvd0=
26. Full article: Global value chains, food and just transition: a multi-scale approach to Brazilian soy value chains - Taylor & Francis Online. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqALis0HwmcY3QOv7WJ7K3lMqRvzkta4VZ5xlvIZD5kvG63F9Dq-6uH81O7qPHz0wUeh4EpdzMGdccUC9L2NTU46Ner6vDTqo0p5jOaL6nrQGeQivDce6wYHAhX4hNdx6tnph7sUGxDiC7F9GuH_u95OdFg5L9VJCxxc=
27. Transition Paths of Brazil from an Agricultural Economy to a Regional Powerhouse: A Global Supply Chain Perspective - MDPI. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJmIK_GIwXlbwZA1r-mvCpQ9-Tet1gYvFu7JkZVO87qBhN78HqFwHVChp2Nof6xjqcINjjEc4ed1mtqnEkHzOLplrGz4QJ-2_yYes6BXlqE2MXUAF70alCOvopkDR8a
28. 1 Descriptive analysis of intergovernmental contracts in the Brazilian Agriculture Ministry Análise descritiva dos contratos in - Revista de Gestão e Secretariado. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJQ8iyW5soBoJYuoAN2UFiwFOLPeEMdMQa3oyX5svu_VM7toiclP2zTz3pMsnlAWZGDiFV4l0QHYFOwKfHUwN_wvGhDEQchXYFe5z7190GOIU6KK_MfjDOPkVDb9NrYoqrA_BU1WxvNoUBLssDC_6lNBx3CuIfgm3E4z7WTMA==
29. PARTNERSHIP SIGNED: SEBRAE and FAO sign agreement to boost the Brazilian agribusiness sector - CONAFER. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAKBmU0ysFff8EF-y_vIilCk54blqB1OMzb2qxJl8mV1SLMT2nyltajISq2QzGAmCABruVgCWU_Ql3wz4uXvY3VwDdrok0UqL6DQoZIJa9wjLYch2iiJ_DEk70aB-GU50hnNW036Dz_PLbbazpoERMeSYGSRzTnIEhlySfS93laMKDH8n8d8rPGkv69-Ns2zfBWW0g8kewDr9k4AAzBiAm6UCbuXI9X4M74=
30. Challenges for building healthy food environment in an agricultural municipality in southern Brazil - SciELO. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqALgdTXXCH-lSqF2-DQtO0-NHxJpdkvAQsnScKXZcgMBe_BW48Yu0hIJ1SlvlqX-Ib9FHqfBSZ6Qo5qsGHzVH85-2Wu0fNjeSJSecxWlfqYXoilUQBMpwHmgaLHZUVZOOinF14HfUBT2-b_Wzg==
31. The Five Dimensions of Food Systems in Brazil: a literature review - Alimentando Políticas. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJjUuqsphVIWfhV6hdgnxSK2-USg41stqvyxMITWx17R7sQ16C119WAzwOIxlTErtp5FQffkXpOcABiyE0Pmp2LtpgN-rhmeAktvfhukOpFahIaZAvfMWV_Za5GEQFXwYgUX3n412VYt6ELluE7DO5YIB-fmlf6iLJQnfX7znGAccXhC_XxkMk_KA1MwrEs_fRzMDOQTKP_GtP9wfVbxMiS3Q==
32. BRAZIL National Pathways to Sustainable Food Systems PART 1 (Introduction). https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJ9lyRbVlHPz54LZP92eTfxpNQNZWa5ZLjkVaJffK-wkmEeTG_dqC5uR-4C4zg6kaQeUbZ9k-5ExxKXm5ziszdDWJLpTmJ96HbzRnt0UWT4ORYowH795LDwL2zPscnWrTv5EbMxBK1WOffVgXNNm0tIhiUsEdVInBWJTiKSUD-zYlXlew4dwGYYydkaafTYKJI3fXVaIOlHNZJW-waHmHleC3BMbUQfB4bv9wdlj1VBpbc0z_akFHE7bIxI5863Dn3bcOcZlDdT
33. The Brazilian Food Value Chain and Competition Policy - Cambridge University Press. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJsa9QvjlbW_0-xWAJRGPOSacbhC7w77SiMjlxFUYxC0DekbyAs-AKpIAsA3GoKyfzDSGoagNaGX56S-GIY0byNKXtOZZFrkzCTPOfs93QZ6XOCgcnr_F5gOqW9iMOHj_nAyYIdg0mo9wVrOHdmvL3BK3iphSdT1dK67pApAnN-KJwumP5gkc8eU4zeTLIJGKQHRi7hGq9-AIenqxATqFcmabYxjZaIBR7VAqIk1rv5j9ndy5YCKGZCqaOmk5mm9m1pdtVyik-ETChEowfM1thDyYcNw-VFRb6ABwU=
34. The contribution of short food supply chains in the formation of ... https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAI_0goJtGeXRnyyba5D4mmwZXMPugB-WI6K-39EyTDJSZft_qSfUUXW9CEDelLJhwXOM4ZOyiZUDELXAIlIIO1sCMJTXX16jkZkEGSvibDYbnERf7tB6TlZVBYH3YNpSVw5tIPmtnUIKu9OcOsfaeUm44VBQ45DaQXAXGk=
35. Brazil and Italy discuss sustainable agriculture in Rome | Brazilian Farmers. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAIWU__P-tth32VZPadqPmxJLe1hU_WuRxHu0xcfdFlYKBL305thXv4BtFOESpC0E6ay0hMm1KZPgUOYRD1CvXgklj91tIttOs7mc0vJZBFOmMMp8NME4sEyAup8TAK0ebxH4DG5QLB4xyiMuRoUxk77h1-PFDWg1ingx3NLFvN3yoInatzoq-2LKq70TKGagrAa
36. The Mercosur – European Union Trade Agreement in the Scope of Brazilian Coffee Agribusiness Sustainability - Cecafé. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAI5gPDGEZWqtChFJAJF1fi0Fa09PTZvLIWwlMsKBv_qnmiKKsk3IH1ZMA_YclkcqRApEcSKBQfvQulOedDSibOq1Af7D8T418wniwRnd8ypanXNilb4F22z7Kn_GR_DTMtJS5s2Jx1c5kZalnL8IBpJpqtqQG11g7-CbcWCeScSBnnphOwBj4RH-uR8EJp-abWs8VQ39hyd7XxhoGYRUd0ku9ST0ic14U3Ui-Y2vkxBvgfsZwWkydVltbErhfv1ukmTc5LuodxlKiFlCeMGXE4jnUM0Tt0sbEG5-YhdpbU=
37. Sustainable Transportation in The Brazilian Agroindustrial Supply Chain: A Literature Review | Revista de Gestão Social e Ambiental. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqALpMlURQUwE-1nbgviRXZKOTElU4r4q2p_K-puK7lz-5rRDnNF8eod39pngXaRX6MN1GTAnqlSXj8m-EzzDAQdFSPdWhHEwd6UcCLceYZJ38-1tJ-f5kB9zTy5ncRS2fzlTFGuBCzizO8hAlaMdinXCOdcg==
38. Brazil's Agribusiness Economic Miracle: Exploring Food Supply Chain Transformations for Promoting Win–Win Investments - MDPI. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJ0K2LdIpYFbfLEETzF2oOGs41ubrVFYxYPnXkCKgiftaI3Wpjqo4BuF-0u94yt4cmeeNsreu9u_JAzqxYP3guvvM0r5V_v0tshmfc0dZ1-K5467uBn8WRVROxn