Value Chain Report on the Food Processing Industry in Brazil

Abstract

This report provides a comprehensive analysis of the food processing industry value chain in Brazil, a sector representing approximately 11% of the nation's GDP in 2024 and responsible for processing over 60% of its agricultural output. The value chain encompasses four primary stages: Agricultural Production, Processing/Agroindustry, Distribution, and Retail/Food Service. Brazil's agricultural strength provides a robust foundation, feeding into a vast processing sector dominated by global giants like JBS, Marfrig, Cargill, and Bunge, alongside significant cooperatives such as Coamo and Aurora Alimentos. The industry generated R$ 1.161 trillion in turnover in 2023. Commercial relationships vary from direct contracts and cooperative agreements to spot market transactions and vertically integrated operations. Key challenges include significant logistical infrastructure deficits, high operational costs, complex regulatory environments, power imbalances favouring large corporations, and increasing pressures for sustainability and food safety compliance. Despite these hurdles, the industry remains a cornerstone of the Brazilian economy, serving a large domestic market (approx. 80% of sales) and holding a position as the world's largest exporter of industrialized food.

Introduction

Overview of the Food Processing Industry in Brazil

The food processing industry stands as a titan within the Brazilian economy, representing the largest industrial sector in the country. In 2023, its turnover reached an impressive R$ 1.161 trillion, marking a 7.2% increase from the previous year. Collectively, the food and beverage industry contributed 11% to Brazil's Gross Domestic Product (GDP) in 2024, with the food processing segment alone accounting for 10.8% of the national GDP. This sector is not only economically significant but also a major employer, providing 1.3 million direct jobs and supporting 5.2 million indirect jobs, which constitutes 25.6% of all employment within Brazil's transformation industry. The industry's core function involves transforming the nation's vast agricultural output – processing 60.9% of all agricultural production – into a diverse array of food and beverage products. While Brazil is the world's largest exporter of industrialized food, selling to over 180 countries, the domestic market remains the primary focus, absorbing approximately 80% of the industry's sales. The sheer scale is further evidenced by the presence of around 45,000 registered processing companies, ranging from multinational corporations to small and medium-sized enterprises and large agricultural cooperatives.

Purpose and Scope of the Report

The purpose of this report is to conduct an in-depth analysis of the value chain structure of the Brazilian food processing industry. It aims to delineate the key stages, identify the main segments and activities within each stage, profile the principal actors shaping the industry landscape, and examine the commercial relationships and business models that govern interactions between these players. Furthermore, the report identifies and analyzes the significant bottlenecks and challenges hindering the efficiency and growth of the value chain. The scope encompasses the entire chain, from the initial agricultural inputs to the final delivery of processed products to consumers via retail and food service channels. By providing a granular and detailed examination of each component, this report seeks to offer valuable insights for industry stakeholders, policymakers, investors, and researchers seeking a comprehensive understanding of this critical sector within the Brazilian economy.

Value Chain Definition

The food processing value chain in Brazil is a complex system transforming raw agricultural commodities into consumable food and beverage products. It can be systematically broken down into four principal stages, each with distinct segments and activities:

1. Agricultural Production: This foundational stage involves the generation of raw materials through farming and livestock raising. It is the source of inputs for the entire subsequent chain.

   • Segments:
     • Crop Production: Encompasses the cultivation of diverse plant-based materials, including essential grains like soybeans (Brazil being a world leader, producing 154 million tons in 2022), corn, and wheat, as well as oilseeds, fruits, vegetables, coffee, and sugar cane.
     • Livestock Production: Focuses on raising animals for meat (beef – Brazil is the second-largest producer globally with a herd of 187.55 million head in 2020; poultry; pork), dairy products (raw milk), and eggs.
   • Main Activities: Include land preparation (tillage, fertilization), planting/seeding, crop management (irrigation, pest/disease control), harvesting, animal breeding and genetics, feeding and nutrition management, animal health monitoring and treatment, milking, egg collection, and the essential initial handling, sorting, and storage of raw products before transport.
   • Types of Players: range from vast large-scale commercial farms leveraging technology and economies of scale, to numerous small and medium-sized family farms forming the backbone of rural production, vital agricultural cooperatives (e.g., Coamo) aggregating member output and providing resources, and integrated producers who manage both farming and subsequent processing stages within a single corporate structure.

2. Processing/Agroindustry: This core stage involves the transformation of raw agricultural products into intermediate or finished food and beverage items. This is where value addition predominantly occurs through various manufacturing processes.

   • Segments:
     • Meat Processing: Slaughtering, deboning, cutting, portioning, cooking, smoking, curing, freezing, and packaging of beef, poultry, and pork products.
     • Dairy Processing: Pasteurization, homogenization, fermentation, churning, and packaging of milk into fluid milk, cheese, yogurt, butter, cream, and milk powders.
     • Grain Processing: Milling of grains (wheat, corn) into flours and meals; crushing of oilseeds (soybeans) for oil extraction and meal production; production of starches, sweeteners, animal feed, and biofuels.
     • Fruit and Vegetable Processing: Juicing, canning, freezing, drying, pickling, and production of purees, concentrates, jams, and jellies.
     • Production of Various Food Products: A broad category encompassing baking (bread, cakes, pastries), confectionery (sweets, chocolate), snack foods (chips, extruded snacks), ready-to-eat meals, sauces, dressings, soups, and infant formula.
     • Beverage Production: Manufacturing of non-alcoholic drinks (soft drinks, juices, bottled water) and alcoholic beverages (beer, wine, spirits).
   • Main Activities: Involve receiving and inspecting raw materials, cleaning, sorting, grading, various transformation processes (e.g., grinding, mixing, heating, cooling, fermenting), formulation and recipe management, sophisticated packaging (aseptic, modified atmosphere), rigorous quality control and assurance protocols, food safety management systems (HACCP, ISO standards), and management of by-products.
   • Types of Players: Include large multinational food corporations (e.g., Cargill, Bunge) with global reach and diversified portfolios, major Brazilian food companies (e.g., JBS, Marfrig, BRF) often specialized in specific sectors like protein, numerous medium and small-sized processing plants catering to regional or niche markets, and agricultural cooperatives that have vertically integrated into processing (e.g., Coamo, Aurora Alimentos) to capture more value for their farmer members.

3. Distribution: This intermediate stage focuses on the logistics of moving processed food and beverage products from the processing plants to the points of final sale. Efficiency in this stage is crucial for maintaining product quality and availability.

   • Segments:
     • Wholesale: Buying large quantities from processors and selling them in smaller lots to retailers, food service companies, and other businesses. Includes large national players often operating cash-and-carry models ('atacarejo').
     • Retail Distribution: Logistics operations managed by large retail chains, often involving dedicated distribution centers, to supply their own network of stores.
     • Food Service Distribution: Specialized distributors catering to the specific needs of restaurants, hotels, hospitals, schools, and other institutional clients, often requiring specialized handling (e.g., temperature control) and delivery schedules.
   • Main Activities: Comprise warehousing (including ambient, refrigerated, and frozen storage), comprehensive inventory management, efficient transportation using various modes (though heavily reliant on road transport in Brazil), complex logistics planning and optimization, order processing and fulfillment, breaking bulk shipments, and sales and account management for business customers.
   • Types of Players: Consist of large wholesale companies (Atacadistas) like Atacadão and Grupo Martins, the distribution arms of major retail chains (e.g., GPA, Carrefour), specialized food service distributors, and smaller independent distributors serving particular regions or market segments.

4. Retail/Food Service: This final stage is where processed food and beverage products become directly accessible to the end consumer through various channels.

   • Segments:
     • Retail: Includes diverse formats such as large hypermarkets offering a vast range of products, supermarkets serving neighbourhood needs, smaller grocery stores (mercados), convenience stores offering quick purchases, specialty food stores focusing on specific categories (e.g., organic, imported), and increasingly important online retail platforms. The retail food sector had a massive turnover of R$ 1.067 trillion in 2024.
     • Food Service (HoReCa - Hotels, Restaurants, Catering): Encompasses restaurants (from fast-food chains to fine dining), cafes and bars, hotels providing food services, institutional catering (for businesses, schools, hospitals), and industrial kitchens.
   • Main Activities: Involve product display and merchandising, managing shelf space, pricing strategies, direct sales transactions, customer service, inventory management at the point of sale, food preparation and cooking (in food service), ensuring compliance with health and safety regulations, and managing home delivery services (especially prevalent in online retail and food service).
   • Types of Players: Include major supermarket chains (e.g., GPA, Carrefour, Atacadão's retail arm), numerous independent grocery stores vital for local communities, various restaurant chains and independent eateries, hotel groups, catering companies, and pure-play online food retailers and delivery platforms.

This structured value chain highlights the journey of food from farm to fork, involving a multitude of specialized players and activities at each interconnected stage.

Players Analysis

The Brazilian food processing value chain is populated by a diverse array of players, from smallholder farmers to global corporations. Below are profiles of some key players, illustrating their roles, activities, and scale within the chain:

• JBS S.A. (Processing - Meat):

  • Profile: A Brazilian multinational company and one of the largest food companies globally by sales, specializing primarily in animal protein (beef, poultry, pork). JBS operates across multiple continents with a vast network of production facilities and distribution channels.
  • Activities: Engages in slaughtering, processing, packaging, and distribution of fresh, frozen, and value-added meat products. Operates strong brands like Friboi, Seara (which includes poultry, pork, and processed foods), Swift, Pilgrim's Pride, and others. Emphasizes commercial execution and innovation in value-added products.
  • Size/Volume: Reported net revenue of R$ 363.82 - 364 billion in 2023. In Q4 2023, JBS Brasil (beef focus) reported R$ 14.9 billion in net revenue, while Seara reported R$ 10.5 billion. Demonstrates significant market dominance in the protein sector. (Ref: 9, 11, 14)

• Marfrig Global Foods S.A. (Processing - Meat):

  • Profile: Another global leader in beef production and one of the largest food companies based in Brazil. Marfrig has substantial operations in South America and North America. Since 2022, it holds controlling interest in BRF, significantly expanding its portfolio into poultry, pork and processed foods.
  • Activities: Primarily involved in the production and processing of beef, including value-added products. Through its control of BRF, it is also heavily involved in poultry, pork, and various processed food items under brands like Sadia and Perdigão.
  • Size/Volume: Reported revenue of R$ 136.49 billion in 2023. Its combined scale with BRF makes it a powerhouse in the South American and global protein market. (Ref: 9, 38)

• BRF S.A. (Processing - Poultry, Pork, Processed Foods):

  • Profile: A major Brazilian food company resulting from the merger of Sadia and Perdigão. It is a leading producer of poultry and pork globally and holds strong brand recognition in Brazil with names like Sadia, Perdigão, and Qualy (margarine). Currently controlled by Marfrig.
  • Activities: Focuses on the production, processing, and sale of poultry, pork, processed meats, frozen prepared meals, margarine, and other food products. Operates a complex production and distribution network.
  • Size/Volume: Reported revenue of R$ 53.62 billion in 2023. Remains one of the largest food companies in Brazil despite recent control changes. (Ref: 9)

• Cargill Agrícola S.A. (Agricultural Production, Processing - Grains/Oilseeds, Ingredients):

  • Profile: The Brazilian subsidiary of the US-based global giant Cargill Inc., one of the "ABCD" companies dominating global agricultural commodity trading (Archer Daniels Midland, Bunge, Cargill, and Louis Dreyfus). Cargill has a vast and diversified presence in Brazil's agribusiness sector.
  • Activities: Involved in originating, processing, and trading grains and oilseeds (soybeans, corn). Produces food ingredients (oils, starches, sweeteners), animal nutrition products, and engages in risk management and financial services related to agriculture. Also involved in direct agricultural production.
  • Size/Volume: Reported revenue of R$ 126.4 billion in Brazil in 2023. A dominant player in grain and oilseed processing and trading. (Ref: 9, 16, 20, 21)

• Bunge Alimentos S.A. (Agricultural Production, Processing - Grains/Oilseeds):

  • Profile: Another member of the "ABCD" group, Bunge is a leading global agribusiness and food company with a long history in Brazil (since 1905).
  • Activities: Primarily focused on oilseed processing (producing oils and meals, mainly from soy), grain milling (wheat and corn), production of food ingredients, sugar and bioenergy, and fertilizer distribution. Owns popular consumer brands in Brazil like Delícia, Primor, Salada, and Soya.
  • Size/Volume: Reported revenue of R$ 81.7 billion in Brazil in 2023. A key player in the soy complex and grain value chains. (Ref: 9, 16, 20, 21, 37)

• Coamo Agroindustrial Cooperativa (Agricultural Production, Processing - Grains):

  • Profile: One of the largest agricultural cooperatives in Latin America, headquartered in Paraná state. Owned by its farmer members.
  • Activities: Involved in receiving, storing, processing, and marketing agricultural products produced by its members, primarily soybeans, corn, wheat, and coffee. Operates processing facilities (e.g., soy crushing, wheat milling), produces refined oils, margarine, and coffee products under its own brands. Also provides inputs and technical assistance to members.
  • Size/Volume: Reported revenue between R$ 28 and 28.22 billion in 2023. Represents over 29,000 associated farmers, demonstrating the scale and importance of the cooperative model in Brazilian agriculture and processing. (Ref: 9, 19, 20)

• Atacadão (Grupo Carrefour Brasil) (Distribution - Wholesale/Retail):

  • Profile: Brazil's largest cash-and-carry (atacarejo) wholesaler, now part of the Carrefour group. Operates a vast network of stores across Brazil.
  • Activities: Sells food and non-food products in bulk and single units to a wide range of customers, including small businesses (retailers, restaurants) and end consumers. Plays a critical role in the distribution landscape, offering competitive pricing through its high-volume, low-cost operating model.
  • Size/Volume: As a key part of Grupo Carrefour Brasil (which reported R$ 108 billion total sales in 2023, though this includes other formats), Atacadão represents a major force in food distribution, contributing significantly to the R$ 1.067 trillion turnover of the retail food sector. (Ref: 13, 32)

• Ambev S.A. (Processing - Beverages):

  • Profile: A major beverage company, part of the Anheuser-Busch InBev group, dominant in the Brazilian beer market and significant in soft drinks. While primarily beverages, it's listed among top agribusiness/food companies due to scale and overlaps.
  • Activities: Production, distribution, and marketing of beer, soft drinks, juices, teas, and other beverages. Operates numerous breweries and bottling plants.
  • Size/Volume: Reported revenue of R$ 79.74 billion in 2023. While mainly beverages, its scale impacts logistics and raw material sourcing (e.g., barley, sugar) interfacing with the broader food chain. (Ref: 9, 38)

• Aurora Alimentos (Cooperativa Central Aurora Alimentos) (Processing - Meat, Dairy):

  • Profile: A large Brazilian food cooperative composed of several affiliated singular cooperatives.
  • Activities: Processes poultry, pork, and dairy products supplied by its cooperative members. Markets products under the Aurora brand and others. Similar to Coamo, it represents a significant vertically integrated cooperative model.
  • Size/Volume: Reported revenue of R$ 21.7 billion in 2023. A major player especially in poultry and pork processing. (Ref: 9)

• Louis Dreyfus Company Brasil (LDC) (Agricultural Production, Processing - Grains/Oilseeds, Juice, Sugar):

  • Profile: Another "ABCD" global commodity trader with significant operations in Brazil.
  • Activities: Involved in processing and trading agricultural commodities like oilseeds (soy), grains (corn), coffee, sugar, cotton, and citrus juices. Operates processing plants, storage facilities, and transportation assets.
  • Size/Volume: Reported revenue of R$ 42.87 billion in Brazil in 2023. (Ref: 9, 21)

These players, with their substantial revenues and market influence, significantly shape the dynamics, competitiveness, and structure of the Brazilian food processing value chain. The presence of large multinationals, strong domestic companies, and powerful cooperatives creates a complex and competitive landscape.

Commercial Relationships

The commercial interactions within Brazil's food processing value chain are multifaceted, ranging from highly formalized contractual agreements to dynamic spot market dealings, significantly influenced by the scale and nature of the participating entities.

• Agricultural Production to Processing: The relationship between farmers and processors is pivotal. Large commercial farms frequently establish direct contracts with major processing companies (e.g., JBS, Cargill, Bunge). These contracts often stipulate precise quality parameters, volumes, delivery timelines, and pricing formulas (fixed price, market-linked index, or a combination), offering predictability for both parties. Contract farming is a specific model where processors might provide inputs (seeds, fertilizers, technical assistance) in exchange for guaranteed supply, reducing farmer market risk but potentially increasing dependence. Small and medium-sized farms often interact with processors via agricultural cooperatives (like Coamo or Aurora). Cooperatives aggregate produce, enhancing negotiating leverage, facilitating logistics, and sometimes undertaking primary processing. They act as crucial intermediaries, providing market access that individual smallholders might struggle to achieve independently. Spot market transactions also exist, especially for easily storable commodities like grains, where farmers sell to the highest bidder (processors, traders, elevators) based on prevailing market prices, offering flexibility but exposing farmers to price volatility. Integrated producers internalize this relationship, as farming operations directly supply their own processing units.

• Processing to Distribution/Retail: Processors sell their finished goods to various downstream channels. Sales to large wholesalers (Atacadistas) and major retail chains (e.g., Carrefour, GPA) typically involve large-volume transactions governed by negotiated contracts. These negotiations can be intense, covering pricing, payment terms (often extended), volume commitments, promotional funding, shelf space allocation (slotting fees), and delivery logistics. The significant market power of large retailers and wholesalers often gives them leverage in these negotiations. Processors also sell to food service distributors, requiring adherence to specific packaging, delivery schedules, and sometimes product customization needed by restaurants and institutional clients. Smaller processors may rely on independent distributors to reach specific geographic regions or niche markets, or engage in direct sales to smaller local retailers or food service outlets.

• Distribution to Retail/Food Service: Wholesalers operate on a B2B model, purchasing in bulk and selling smaller quantities to retailers (especially independent ones) and food service establishments. Their commercial relationship focuses on volume discounts, efficient logistics, and reliable supply. Retail chains often manage their own distribution networks, procuring directly from processors or large wholesalers to supply their stores. Food service distributors maintain relationships with numerous restaurants, hotels, and caterers, providing a wide product portfolio and frequent, often just-in-time, deliveries.

• Retail/Food Service to Consumer: This final link is predominantly B2C. Retailers interact with consumers through the point of sale (physical or online), focusing on product assortment, price, quality, promotions, and shopping experience. Food service establishments sell prepared food and experiences, with the commercial relationship based on menu offerings, service quality, ambiance, and price. E-commerce platforms have introduced new digital relationship models, involving online ordering, payment, and delivery logistics.

Across these stages, power dynamics are evident. Large multinational processors and traders, along with major consolidated retail chains, typically hold significant bargaining power relative to smaller farmers, independent distributors, or smaller retailers. This can influence price negotiations, payment terms, and contractual conditions throughout the chain.

Bottlenecks and Challenges

The Brazilian food processing value chain, despite its scale and global importance, contends with significant bottlenecks and structural challenges that impact its efficiency, competitiveness, and sustainability.

• Logistical Infrastructure Deficiencies: This is arguably the most critical bottleneck. Brazil's vast territory, combined with underdeveloped and poorly maintained infrastructure, creates major hurdles.

  • Transportation: Over-reliance on costly road transport, often hampered by poor road quality, leads to high freight costs, delays, and product losses (especially for perishables). Railway and waterway networks are insufficient alternatives for many key agricultural routes connecting production zones (like the Center-West) to processing centers and ports (mainly in the South and Southeast).
  • Storage: Insufficient storage capacity, particularly at the farm level and inland aggregation points, struggles to keep pace with increasing agricultural output (especially grains). This can force producers into rushed sales post-harvest when prices may be lower and increases the risk of spoilage and quantitative losses.
  • Ports: Congestion and inefficiencies at major ports hinder export flows, adding costs and reducing the global competitiveness of Brazilian products.

• High Operational Costs: Processors and other players face a challenging cost environment. High energy costs, significant logistics expenses (as mentioned above), complex and burdensome taxation (the 'Custo Brasil'), and relatively high labor costs compared to some competitors squeeze margins. Volatility in raw material prices and currency fluctuations further complicate financial planning and investment decisions. High interest rates make accessing affordable capital for investment and working capital difficult.

• Bureaucracy and Regulatory Complexity: Navigating Brazil's regulatory landscape is often complex and time-consuming. Obtaining licenses and permits, registering new products or ingredients, and complying with various federal, state, and municipal regulations can be burdensome, particularly for smaller enterprises. Proposed changes, such as potentially shifting meat inspection responsibilities from federal inspectors to industry-paid technicians, raise concerns about maintaining rigorous food safety standards, potentially impacting consumer trust and vital export market access. Overlapping jurisdictions between different government agencies can also create confusion and delays.

• Power Imbalances and Farmer Vulnerability: Significant asymmetries exist, particularly between smallholder farmers and large agribusiness corporations (processors, input suppliers, traders). Farmers often face limited bargaining power when negotiating prices for their crops or purchasing essential inputs (seeds, fertilizers, pesticides), potentially leading to unfavorable terms and increased indebtedness. The "Soybean Trap" exemplifies this, where dependence on a single commodity chain can expose producers to significant market and financial risks controlled by larger players.

• Access to Credit and Financing: While government programs exist, accessing sufficient and affordable credit remains a challenge for many farmers (especially smallholders) and small-to-medium-sized processors. This limitation restricts investment in technology, productivity enhancements, storage solutions, and overall business expansion.

• Environmental Sustainability and Compliance: Growing global and domestic demand for sustainable practices puts pressure on the entire value chain. Concerns regarding deforestation (especially in the Amazon and Cerrado biomes linked to soy and cattle expansion), water resource management, pesticide use, and carbon footprint require significant attention. Meeting stricter environmental regulations and international market expectations for traceability and sustainability certification is becoming increasingly crucial for market access but requires investment and changes in practices.

• Market Concentration: Certain segments within the value chain exhibit high levels of market concentration. Key examples include meat processing (dominated by JBS, Marfrig/BRF), grain trading and processing (the "ABCD" companies), and retail (consolidation among major supermarket chains). This concentration can limit competition, potentially impacting prices for consumers and terms for suppliers.

• Food Safety and Quality Assurance: Ensuring consistent food safety and quality across a vast and fragmented production base (especially involving many small producers) is an ongoing challenge. Maintaining robust inspection, monitoring, and traceability systems is critical for public health and maintaining access to demanding export markets. Regulatory uncertainties regarding inspection protocols add complexity.

• Formalization Hurdles for Small Agro-industries: Small, family-based agro-industries often face difficulties in navigating the complex sanitary, environmental, and tax requirements needed for formal registration. This can limit their access to broader markets, credit, and government support programs.

• Adapting to Shifting Consumer Demands: Consumers, particularly in urban centers and international markets, are increasingly demanding healthier options (low sugar, low fat, natural ingredients), convenient products (ready-to-eat meals), ethically sourced items, and foods with clear sustainability credentials (organic, non-GMO, deforestation-free). The industry needs continuous innovation and adaptation to meet these evolving preferences, which can be challenging and costly.

Addressing these multifaceted challenges is essential for unlocking the full potential of Brazil's food processing value chain, enhancing its efficiency, sustainability, and long-term global competitiveness.

Value Chain Relationships and Business Models

The intricate network of relationships within the Brazilian food processing value chain is underpinned by diverse commercial interactions and specific business models adopted by players at each stage. These models determine how value is created, captured, and exchanged, while transactions face specific bottlenecks.

Commercial Relationships: Products and Services Exchanged

• Agricultural Production -> Processing: Farmers supply raw commodities (grains, livestock, milk, fruits, etc.). Services include initial transport, basic sorting, and services provided by cooperatives (technical assistance, storage, collective marketing).
• Processing -> Distribution: Processors supply finished, packaged goods (processed meats, dairy products, flours, oils, beverages, ready meals, etc.). Services include contract manufacturing, co-packing, quality testing, and R&D.
• Distribution -> Retail/Food Service: Distributors supply a wide range of processed food items. Services include warehousing, inventory management, logistics and transportation, order fulfillment, and sales support. Wholesalers provide bulk-breaking services.
• Retail/Food Service -> Consumer: Retailers offer processed food and beverage products. Services include merchandising, customer service, store operations (physical/online), and delivery. Food service provides prepared meals and dining experiences.

Business Models Employed

• Agricultural Production:

  • Independent Farming: Focus on operational efficiency, yield maximization, and direct sales (spot or contract).
  • Cooperatives: Collective action model for input purchasing, processing, marketing, risk sharing, and member support (e.g., Coamo, Aurora).
  • Contract Farming: Risk mitigation model based on pre-agreed terms with buyers, often involving input provision.
  • Integrated Production: Vertical integration model controlling farming and processing for supply chain control (common among large poultry/pork companies).

• Processing/Agroindustry:

  • Large-Scale Industrial Processing: Mass production model leveraging economies of scale, strong branding, and extensive distribution (e.g., JBS, Ambev, Cargill).
  • Specialty/Niche Processing: Focus on differentiation, high value-added, specific market segments (organic, gourmet).
  • Cooperative Processing: Vertically integrated model adding value to members' produce within the cooperative structure.
  • Ingredient Suppliers: B2B model focused on producing standardized inputs for other food manufacturers (e.g., Bunge, Cargill's ingredient divisions).

• Distribution:

  • Wholesale (Atacado/Atacarejo): High-volume, low-margin model based on logistics efficiency, serving businesses and sometimes consumers (e.g., Atacadão).
  • Retail Distribution Centers: Internal logistics model for large chains, optimizing own store supply.
  • Food Service Distribution: Specialized model offering tailored product ranges and delivery services to HoReCa clients.
  • Independent Distribution: Niche model relying on local market knowledge and personalized service.

• Retail/Food Service:

  • Super/Hypermarket Chains: High-volume retail model based on wide assortment, competitive pricing, and customer experience (e.g., Carrefour, GPA).
  • Neighborhood Grocery: Convenience model focused on local communities.
  • Cash-and-Carry (Atacarejo): Hybrid wholesale/retail model offering bulk/unit sales at low prices.
  • Food Service Establishments: Experience-based model focusing on food quality, service, and ambiance.
  • E-commerce/Delivery Platforms: Technology-driven model offering convenience and direct-to-consumer fulfillment.

Bottlenecks in Transactions

Commercial relationships and transactions along the value chain are frequently impeded by the broader challenges facing the industry:

• Logistics Costs & Delays: Transactions involving physical product movement (farmer to processor, processor to distributor, distributor to retailer) are directly impacted by high transport costs and infrastructure inefficiencies, affecting pricing and delivery reliability.
• Pricing Volatility & Negotiation Asymmetry: Spot market transactions expose farmers to price risks. In contract negotiations, power imbalances between large buyers (processors, retailers) and smaller suppliers (farmers, smaller processors) can lead to unfavorable terms, particularly regarding price and payment schedules.
• Information Asymmetry: Lack of transparent market information can disadvantage smaller players in negotiations.
• Regulatory Hurdles: Delays in approvals or complex compliance requirements can slow down the introduction of new products or ingredients, affecting commercial timelines.
• Quality & Safety Compliance: Ensuring consistent quality and safety standards agreed upon in contracts can be challenging, potentially leading to disputes or rejected shipments, particularly when dealing with numerous small suppliers. Traceability requirements add complexity to transactions.
• Access to Finance: Limited working capital can strain relationships, particularly regarding payment terms demanded by large buyers versus the needs of smaller suppliers.

These bottlenecks highlight friction points within the commercial relationships, often requiring specific strategies (like robust contracts, strong partnerships, or technological solutions for traceability) to mitigate risks and ensure smoother transactions.

Conclusion

Summary of Findings

The Brazilian food processing industry operates within a complex, dynamic, and economically vital value chain. Stretching from extensive agricultural production, fueled by Brazil's natural resource wealth, through a massive and diverse processing sector, into sophisticated distribution networks, and finally reaching consumers via multiple retail and food service channels, the chain is a cornerstone of the national economy. Key players include global agribusiness giants, powerful domestic corporations specialized in protein and other sectors, large and influential agricultural cooperatives, and a vast number of small and medium-sized enterprises. Commercial relationships are varied, encompassing formal contracts, cooperative structures, spot market interactions, and vertically integrated models, often marked by significant power asymmetries between large corporations and smaller players. The industry processes a majority of Brazil's agricultural output, employs millions, and contributes significantly to GDP. However, its efficiency and growth are constrained by critical challenges, most notably severe logistical infrastructure deficits (transport, storage), high operational costs, regulatory complexities, difficulties in accessing finance, environmental pressures demanding greater sustainability, and the need to constantly adapt to evolving consumer preferences and ensure robust food safety standards.

Recommendations or Areas for Further Research

Based on the analysis, several areas warrant attention:

• Infrastructure Investment: Targeted public and private investment in transportation (railways, waterways, road maintenance) and storage infrastructure is paramount to reduce logistics costs and improve efficiency.
• Regulatory Simplification: Streamlining regulatory processes, reducing bureaucracy, and ensuring clear, stable food safety regulations (including inspection protocols) would benefit players across the chain, particularly SMEs.
• Strengthening Smallholder Positions: Initiatives to enhance the bargaining power of small farmers and processors, such as fostering stronger cooperatives, promoting fair trade practices, and improving access to market information and finance, are crucial for inclusive growth.
• Promoting Sustainability: Continued research and investment in sustainable agricultural practices, traceability systems, and circular economy models within the processing stage are needed to meet environmental goals and market demands.
• Innovation and Value Addition: Encouraging R&D and innovation in processing technologies, new product development (especially targeting health and convenience trends), and branding can enhance competitiveness and value capture.
• Further Research: Deeper quantitative analysis of market shares within specific processing segments, detailed mapping of regional variations in value chain structure and challenges, comparative analysis of different business models' performance (e.g., cooperatives vs. integrated producers), and impact assessment of specific regulations on value chain actors would provide valuable further insights.

Addressing these areas through collaborative efforts between industry, government, and research institutions can help the Brazilian food processing industry overcome its challenges and solidify its position as a sustainable and globally competitive leader.

References

(Note: References are listed based on their appearance and utility in generating the report sections from the provided context documents. Numbering corresponds to the original list in the context.)

1. Faturamento da indústria de alimentos cresceu 7,2% em 2023, para R$ 1,161 trilhão, diz Abia | Exame. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAIk5NuBtg2lzaV1dci-32ATOEiX7SDSpwgS4SJ4AZzgfDFPhEi7kBng11sQhWpNqIhDMc8yv8Q5MxHTyFdcgCJn9wmjPVDSZMLGCAITi4ztg_1mKiudOGOeIYQ_zB5tLb0Sa5ldEdr_rtlVs_V7_gnr65vHkGpSSePS3Jo5L11nJ_J4ShBrMt6ofiIQ2gwqwv-UYzLTjWNz_geh0C23etCmHSelPwyeKw==
2. A Soja - Aprosoja Brasil. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJQkxrwwvBHAO2OHuBa-0VAT_nUcJF4xdOJKvnhFKAH9ih8F77LUu33WyKkpo_-lMJWpmWAuCTACzEupC70vGAfhW1n_v9-gSaK4lDRqq_gRPpgPFQlX9qU4C4H
3. Indústria brasileira de alimentos e bebidas cresce 10% em faturamento e representa 11% do PIB em 2024 - Aditivos | Ingredientes. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJiSt8QrmIUzQUca4bxi7GieccS9CrBHb_ltrOAnVoA_48kSTk9KY9uT9ARx6x93fDqdhs0EccdM3FShcaO2Ce07a-wPJ44SS2Lfz_5Nru7309RdxLKlZ3kDz9GRAW3aBjOBRCVpNlHTl8nMhbCyWngyTHnsHPlJgPRhSnwDey_mIB3-TBhQc4G8TvTDOuHfxUIh9jlU2vnVY9Vdwakv943dzu_EyeUoAc9Rs_BEKPtt3BLb9oTdblEaoH-d6I1ejazw-XvLJ3Bh2H-2aWs18hKGpp03PFGky9jcudcyg=
4. Faturamento da indústria de alimentos cresceu 7,2% em 2023, para R$ 1,161 trilhão, diz Abia - ISTOÉ DINHEIRO. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAIUZS88vBmSH5GFWfZplRPhhqUcL_-Ln-JaZBnCVoiXDI7t_twfSavSwxLv1f0_QVw7ZzfBZUP0PLZp2C3rXGVquArMEdM0E8PWGewVXZPmWZ89WhdBeD2ysLCVA-U2B1Gb5hY2xgbvcgn8zEmFnvPqh4yzY9K1t8S2NCkAG09N21OlvRZl8ARI4wfLmjnLVYgxGtl3lyacL4T7C1-1CMqPu_ps9PQhO44
5. Em 2022, Sorriso (MT) manteve a liderança na produção agrícola | Agência de Notícias. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqALxv6eiRrAA_VQD9RI5UJ95-oDzm4qeVB5fhdmM3DuXvM72lvs9MtHS3Io1l-WGJYabniu4AUY9zLOUFsa7vxF-pxf5hjyLZ2rUJShrD05zM8rn5mCH_LRGiHYFCPzDwG0nQ3ocjKu3hz0JMP7R3EbhZF3yPnixXWPM7UR-YeDC4MZrKSv8TA_-gSmyahI11-SDFULBuy_U2E4h0rzjhvxrc7MNZQ8ge4nZEtU2D6JPQUDpFBIepn-u3jrQqwGa_14AtHYzePybwHTS1MAOSIpuUQ==
6. Indústria de alimentos fatura R$ 1,2 trilhão em 2023, alta de 7,2% - Poder360. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAI7BklIhC8LEMzPr-gL304dtlMYVN1wVqITskJ9du_0kAVgw97ibr-nHKExmjKTNKmat7UO5veRdU78K1lez6HfpDt4uczX6pFCDntiBjCmWsBICj-uhifNraNfwWFczAmOkQtpVLLLctDjfyVu-sJZ1NFWNMUuiSxbTH8bfmtjqHYSV3Fu3TxhEBGtdEq0yJeb8rOlxMgMR4w=
7. Veja a lista das 100 maiores empresas do agronegócio do Brasil - Forbes. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAIrRlhLUYUoyVu2-oEZs1-0oDf6PBzOxH5zZzWQNeAud32cJzMzKtzT25NUPUMW3DyklM9Ozj11JvxWIf2-4RCyQQWhErJ9nG1MQBQmIldDhxIQsTjrtPH9F2XqXTi8R4soRUAbmyMKveGnki9V0SO_2XLNKRvHbzvxE736BJplFEh-DbYJ_28oXhJuKgnsU1Vytces=
8. Indústria de alimentos processados - USDA Brazil. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJoCPGb-NoydIHFyGno3nH8-knYWwNtd6p4LMmoKnU0Ym4HGetaKoEn93JBp9TSuvth2O_INDOOTGyFDfKVg1gGt2pcfgS77dkb3-s1gjLmZR_8PqtcAh3RGDDsFOIqGnich8wiy2AqNuWQXucknb7soPI1
9. JBS registra receita líquida de R$ 364 bilhões e Ebitda de R$ 17 bilhões em 2023. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAI2GYVRKCPiKRrl4TZYLQvWQof1eSOHgeeBAUpX5yaI82C8_zi9CvFBUuGeloYURW97VtFbXfisW9QbXXoXYXPjPtCGDhQBckwHnF1o7HSjiYB3qLrOJIjZmkUNlEXqwT1Rd2-zLOLkK4ACKGI278MXY4VPNfmBEl8f6bLMsevNgzmyRsXpP_EDdxzQXkPRyWx3wsG76VLiPVGh2o_A7Vie4AGt
10. Maiores atacadistas e distribuidores do país são premiados na Convenção - ABAD. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAIGaikI5YzpYSI8m0huJ5P-frDtU43nk2iDu2VJb9p0UUc4Zc890_rFikut7HVKqBeXrotqsYBuB9-GJPDdZjmXh57fiOnX0VK5PcepjmLLbxCVHpPsCVZmYID_NGmxyBIA6fBAF-UhF_LWci8-bFZg7BnMlJUAa3tPtr55lCo8cE9KQ3Vk2eiI0WxT8IR_Wez6tAB9zTKflYrppBBhLPgXol9T
11. Mapa divulga os 100 municípios mais ricos do agronegócio em 2023 - Portal Gov.br. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAKjXHde4rQLBGjTevGIcOp4iFyDpPa6k9ccp2F2wNPvuu6JkeFN3GvKi0Qbiulg7iTW8mV0QFTghIA_IDSWdvKYu8g3-RjxJYfy0FDCBYEWLdbtzuIkEKSHCQR1TBD1ckWDKzfTqE5kJSe4rNEcrDRWxtAHc8k94t143GOsXOeAU98SDL97BuuIr8R_62oojKjkCewVXB9ik7G2YLS9pHjbTJtHGeJwmacUItYmMQ==
12. Impressionante: Apenas 5 empresas dominam até 90% do mercado mundial de grãos. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqALAnKo_iS2adDxtQf7skdPDlPz3PxuANL2xPWHQd-YNQiZ_Kzk7MPOPPLfFVAzNlFtTHFcuj-vMuitIy3gF1iV3_hMc4pub6FMI9gIenZc3RMshHeKpvM-7F_6BEIFepb8qhFzPLL4a11FKYNI-evcwWPI7wx1Gy88EacPoKeBSvsHg6DXHnAN9KrmX175LkgItkURPOIkmKIYiaKgvA==
13. Empresas de insumos agrícolas: conheça as 10 melhores - TerraMagna. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAKvasZDuSiNlQilI-QGZVulO57L_Ygs3wKRyPgJPpvuhPthCinblH7AwdM_2yAQTE3puqMY5BCPcxCr04fJfOjJCAfvXQm-4Y1g6AdKzPKpINTl8xIVDMRHFceF8bO31-Li1n5SKFnNb5I_Pb2yrgR_fIc6
14. As 100 maiores empresas do agronegócio brasileiro em 2020 - Forbes. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAI4yS_GPjWsyzB9kwxNPmONZdrdwxlEyEwcKeIF8RcD3JwpQ-DcUjQNZPXXqe5RHJjDvchduMPieahnyhgh21FnpHu4nAOjaCuC71H-lurTGHYyNZfvw4RQAn0nQd-cLXnFQbv8blW-PHdZ4iALPCajrnt4C78CR-ZvQvRib0Pf5QZxqQHQX3v5c2T3S-0DZBvJKyIeE_iBa74=
15. ABCD do Agro: Entendendo o Domínio das Gigantes do Agronegócio - VAROS. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqALAyxAjUocC1He6B9e3qMcWjrf7iUy6qQl23687EP8Rmboom9IdLq9nuanY0RquTZVjdzKHeCJdRJZDJZTgiSG5u6ouWTjf-s1ix_C03q-qwO3zY9zBZzqht9aOQS8tPg0JQIjiMo7HvQujGesc2zCSURjS5GE2LxkY_0MLcLI=
16. A PECUÁRIA DE CORTE NO BRASIL: UMA ABORDAGEM SISTÊMICA DA PRODUÇÃO A DIFERENCIAÇÃO DE PRODUTOS. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJgmFwgENA27W0kiRfqC0Tkfa_kFVjF2LEc7GQ7Z59MS6-vAnvVr_NUtcmdp3tKtvOkMS2obVe4XWwTaoQFWWBBxIwjWcsPUSAFEqFhMcja0vu1Krekfixo6AHks6Ys9cSXsXQ=
17. Números do setor - ABIA - Associação Brasileira da Indústria de Alimentos. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAKC12vbx_JzApCh9lkmoqfVu5V1S4-iesSzC33lhWDUAXfv3756LQ2-cm0F9m14VMpvGhy7IDvLzGoMAC764A6vX-3dVOkYNvDNCspByxVEDctk6UaGjkK8asbb
18. Ranking ABRAS 2025: As maiores empresas do varejo alimentar brasileiro - Instabuy. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAKvfXtn-1S6PGLxxFIqkVWP_MkYYmUWuwLBj02bTyHG1h20Zmf9xSc_UGy88h3unOZJlpwnPSSKVCOgxhCJ5lDxpptUHPMxoKKnWNk3WZtBv5ErYa6sqlxRQL7w-Dfydll6Or2ROYStV8aNcqtp-m3Ms6ulVeUcF-Jucjfg3mIh_HOjq1Z1s1SMptbLSq9VBDjt
19. Bunge destaca modelo de gestão sustentável na cadeia de valor. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAIicsrmwlkvcw1oxIsClwrYm-DEmsZs26vnqvV-9AITjNNYl0E7qgXey8lyZLpzCegqKOeFbMYS1Q_zRYdw13mKPQGJXmelV3YKp2MuXKIZnpU6b3kARZaGKdtg7jAhL9v3x4kLj78I_kCZpnz6x3VAI8elKo3VaI6TR_9HdhugV2O1oZ-FdyOpYHWgbk7fd6IPdIuoYAUlwkw=
20. 14 maiores fábricas de alimentos no Brasil - Só Hélices. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJsczwYxGRp7DZMah-0LEI8WMF2eYEWrosJ-YcZrLegBiEcnxOCA0QY9HMefU8jj-azLFF5h7rrjAmh41aV5hWFKmH69HM3yET7t7fgOJ-kSo0gMn3HjyOQSYySVTi0GCiEeZbHXJY17JXbb57vTwBXq7ty12KQ28FI6g==
21. A pecuária, que é uma das principais e mais importantes atividades do Brasil, está sendo celebrada nesta sexta-feira | Portal da Alego. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJEY7--z52NECYi390asxQPIqWmuDcQO5kJA-4xY20RUwxtHEkQQOHVk1INEmj30XxzyBiiJWfIEBD9zTzP2FS6VEAYTchfut43Jh2i4UyHVTqSox5p9EAiFxyrhvXFrWul-D5NQDcf8bLMlCO46TuBBgDkEjCvLEmsHrSeg7yVRqHFWN-i0UkP5wzxbUEG5pa-pJGGmSA_x13tJKvnKE5Eq6u_UlV3_yFsAafj9t8BfVq9iR-coyhbHno6Ebfe1nAiCCdDToUgfStzyc1ziQ69Izw2eQ0=

(References from the second context document "Value Chain Analysis of the Food Processing in Brazil.")

1. FINAL TRANSFER Food Processing Report Brazil - Agroberichten Buitenland. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJuTq6n_sBIyRpA24yj5QQu_NMsSq8D_zNkbPADyuAHBlglU9sFATZnsNk041DoE7Tqw-S05tixJ2UpGsHpH_3juZFlqOmkPmGOdpXVFCIOLTycqD9FqLvf56tYj-rovt6UBK_TO0907BnCBNVlNe-WGf-KV6qgEimKuSKGv6s83vglzyNCqo3Xzo8fWCMC16Z0JvNYc-NyiZeNBwCbDslWoWrUERzVCyQD0xcl-lUhksjMtVrIVNmsliRNcT1wUt_R0tKnddApwQM9NYR8A6OfowFn2QTuXPSJwFL95VFLRJLeLNTNmFS1nZfe3I2_xiN8lWAJuTNlhk0RuBX3
2. Brazil's Momentum as a Global Agricultural Supplier Faces Headwinds - ers.usda.gov. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAIF8V09y70ARb4xNTWYfxGtBgsnMYBF7Dap3bBR29sYZj2Yg3VP2GFQViW2fwWz91XuMrIabGusbcAQ4xcrrSneE3La-6lMO4OaG_gHZ-TgcAW7dCenEjrXjtMHrPKs7xEKIYtL2Yj3Go_9ctmgQwHYPjXY8xgIIfNZtCwNE-axVmpgCRQm9HjkEcBfDGAMnRa1ytFies4zhdTHkiitDnUBRrSn3J1owE9xhC0DWQ==
3. The New Brazilian Law on Contract Farming. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJJdL1_x1v487hLAYvX15w6lnUVP38Ts3_AxyflG-swCcPgCNSkbNKc0pAnlOEan0W4IdgWhK1nxFyyGX8qsJANLEdXgK8BXyVoqMnQlw9f6HNsC1od7TMo88WI_Og8iZ_MkWSVtq2fA2GA4HzW2I24pO3ItKVKuUOuDoU2-V2Ww23MiNAC_9pVDCqSr2zJOIYY8Bt0wxSVZJFRnzvSiESHgsJP9MUyYGrE_yiufPrzaR8NBG-1mdcozruu_Es=
4. Brazil's Meat Inspection Standards at Risk Due to Regulatory Changes - iGrow News. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAIPL06R-ahFy4XndKBr3IlZz867fWxrwsjHWZaD_Dy4aswbcysuJOhroETKlHfbENoDEGFpuG8eZ9BU611ZBwa1k_9Me5wIaUjmW75EhzfS8tqZXJN9rWtxCPQFpnico3JXH7udpwpdsdtZF4MWscnBJxlz8Gj1aeJ1hB_rV2Y47KPEwOlt5xY6INUaMloaJxo=
5. Production and Protection: A First Look at Key Challenges in Brazil - Climate Policy Initiative. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAIBqGcpz0Y4hyGiIa7dzc3GJ4FMNeZtXnz0g-3ILyHuD9prmFbjr3QQOGVO9mQLWpKqLb1NfciahvN4uZRaeQT_cjLa0H-9xgJfIBxew59DN8XTIYm6wIcr0RjsnWLtT55nMaLmPy9UPHA7YpuY6WNizcVy3AQ4GfIKsbW0ehntDHYRQIhUB2XetkD-Gzr62yBm8WD13LEL9vwIxCYAkydVgAGdsJK7nyzG3GP1f0P3STvGMVVL_SuOOYV2ug==
6. The Soybean Trap: Challenges and Risks for Brazilian Producers - Frontiers. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAIn3ETPjPHBu4SGna4dYHD7wXhWo6cV2T_qXyDD84r5JXbtzQ2-iZTyzsUFs775Q9cXRYQxLYvCBuLkmeoibyI3iGPsFEuGYRwdytGdeJAu0OEQzlVEnRXDGpJQ7jyOYe-61TwiMuqx6-yL35YzpnN-d4Ujj1NOyOda2FrZbPtjOBKALjKNRgRN8QJJZeYwNt_miEFVwkcmERnK
7. PUBLIC FOOD PROCUREMENT FROM SMALLHOLDER FARMERS – THE BRAZILIAN EXPERIENCE - Global Child Nutrition Foundation. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAIx-j-6C-dN-lC5fsVNbfzVIc6PcSWgUnWXC6GZuX3iRoOvjahHqYiATvRf0ChiOMSsze-soQ0orMVD7zxN4L8cKtVfqcpMG0iQklQaXyknHspp1sgKjLTWHeNyQtPMAC-UyEwcBdaaM98di2o_-uRYWRbsaY143J3bmBvEpDshi579cSS3zuCjRkpgyn1gvEpA5D3HQ80PCTYs
8. PARTNERSHIP SIGNED: SEBRAE and FAO sign agreement to boost the Brazilian agribusiness sector - CONAFER. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAKBmU0ysFff8EF-y_vIilCk54blqB1OMzb2qxJl8mV1SLMT2nyltajISq2QzGAmCABruVgCWU_Ql3wz4uXvY3VwDdrok0UqL6DQoZIJa9wjLYch2iiJ_DEk70aB-GU50hnNW036Dz_PLbbazpoERMeSYGSRzTnIEhlySfS93laMKDH8n8d8rPGkv69-Ns2zfBWW0g8kewDr9k4AAzBiAm6UCbuXI9X4M74=
9. Challenges for building healthy food environment in an agricultural municipality in southern Brazil - SciELO. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqALgdTXXCH-lSqF2-DQtO0-NHxJpdkvAQsnScKXZcgMBe_BW48Yu0hIJ1SlvlqX-Ib9FHqfBSZ6Qo5qsGHzVH85-2Wu0fNjeSJSecxWlfqYXoilUQBMpwHmgaLHZUVZOOinF14HfUBT2-b_Wzg==
10. The Brazilian Food Value Chain and Competition Policy - Cambridge University Press. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqAJsa9QvjlbW_0-xWAJRGPOSacbhC7w77SiMjlxFUYxC0DekbyAs-AKpIAsA3GoKyfzDSGoagNaGX56S-GIY0byNKXtOZZFrkzCTPOfs93QZ6XOCgcnr_F5gOqW9iMOHj_nAyYIdg0mo9wVrOHdmvL3BK3iphSdT1dK67pApAnN-KJwumP5gkc8eU4zeTLIJGKQHRi7hGq9-AIenqxATqFcmabYxjZaIBR7VAqIk1rv5j9ndy5YCKGZCqaOmk5mm9m1pdtVyik-ETChEowfM1thDyYcNw-VFRb6ABwU=
11. Sustainable Transportation in The Brazilian Agroindustrial Supply Chain: A Literature Review | Revista de Gestão Social e Ambiental. https://vertexaisearch.cloud.google.com/grounding-api-redirect/AWQVqALpMlURQUwE-1nbgviRXZKOTElU4r4q2p_K-puK7lz-5rRDnNF8eod39pngXaRX6MN1GTAnqlSXj8m-EzzDAQdFSPdWhHEwd6UcCLceYZJ38-1tJ-f5kB9zTy5ncRS2fzlTFGuBCzizO8hAlaMdinXCOdcg==