Skip to content

Value Chain Analysis of the Banking in Chile.

The banking industry in Chile operates through a dynamic and interconnected value chain, which, unlike linear manufacturing processes, involves simultaneous and ongoing activities that create and deliver a wide spectrum of financial products and services. This analysis delves into the detailed structure of this value chain, examining the commercial relationships that bind the various players, the specific products and services that flow through these connections, the underlying business models that drive profitability, and the critical bottlenecks and challenges currently shaping the industry, particularly within the 2024-2025 timeframe. The analysis is grounded in the context of Chile's specific economic and regulatory environment, including the significant influence of the Comisión para el Mercado Financiero (CMF) and the Banco Central de Chile, and the evolving landscape shaped by the implementation of the Fintech Law and Basel III standards.

Commercial Relationships

Commercial relationships within the Chilean banking value chain are diverse and fundamental to its operation, extending beyond the direct bank-customer interaction to encompass a complex ecosystem of financial and non-financial entities. These relationships are characterized by varying degrees of formality, from contractual agreements to ongoing service partnerships and regulatory oversight.

The initial stage, Funding/Resource Gathering, is built upon the commercial relationship between banks and providers of capital. The most prevalent relationship is with depositors – individuals, small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), large corporations, and other financial institutions. This relationship is commercially driven by the bank's need for stable funding and the depositors' desire for security, liquidity, and interest income on their funds. Different types of deposits (checking, savings, time deposits) represent distinct product offerings within this relationship, each with its own terms and conditions. Beyond deposits, banks establish commercial relationships with institutional investors and participants in wholesale money markets through the issuance of debt instruments like bonds. These relationships are governed by financial contracts outlining interest payments, maturity dates, and other terms. Accessing lines of credit from other financial institutions also falls under this category, representing a commercial relationship for short-term funding needs.

In the core stage of Financial Intermediation/Transformation, the primary commercial relationship is between banks, acting as lenders, and borrowers, encompassing individuals seeking personal or mortgage loans, and businesses (SMEs and large corporations) requiring financing for operations or investments. These relationships are formalized through loan agreements and credit contracts, defining interest rates, repayment schedules, collateral requirements, and other terms. The commercial aspect lies in the exchange of capital for the promise of future repayment with interest, which constitutes the bank's primary revenue source in this model. Banks also maintain commercial relationships with other financial institutions through interbank lending and participation in syndicated loans, which are large loans provided by a group of banks to a single borrower. These are governed by specific interbank agreements.

The Product and Service Development & Delivery stage involves a wide array of commercial relationships with third-party providers and other entities within the financial ecosystem. Banks contract with technology companies for the development and maintenance of their digital platforms, including online banking, mobile applications, and internal systems. Relationships with payment networks (like Visa and Mastercard) and local payment infrastructure providers are crucial for facilitating transactions via debit and credit cards and electronic transfers. The emergence of the Fintech Law has fostered new commercial relationships between traditional banks and fintech companies, often through partnerships or collaborations to offer innovative services like payment initiation or specialized lending platforms. These relationships are typically governed by partnership agreements, service level agreements, and data sharing protocols, especially with the advent of Open Finance. Furthermore, banks have commercial relationships with ATM operators, call center providers, and other service providers to ensure the delivery of services through various channels. The relationship with the end customer at this stage is transactional, focused on providing a specific product or service in exchange for fees, interest, or other charges.

Relationship Management & Servicing is built on the ongoing commercial interaction between banks and their customers, aimed at fostering loyalty and maximizing the lifetime value of the customer relationship. For retail and commercial banking, this involves customer service interactions, account management, and addressing inquiries, often through dedicated relationship managers for larger clients or digital channels for individuals and SMEs. In private banking and corporate banking, the relationships are highly personalized and involve dedicated financial advisors providing tailored advice and solutions. The commercial aspect here is the provision of ongoing support and advisory services, often linked to fees for assets under management or specific financial planning services.

While not strictly commercial in the traditional sense of revenue generation, the relationships in Risk Management & Compliance are critical and involve interactions with regulatory bodies like the CMF and the Banco Central de Chile. These are mandatory relationships involving the regular submission of financial data, compliance reports, and participation in audits and inspections. Banks also have commercial relationships with external auditors and legal firms to ensure compliance with regulations and manage legal risks. Credit rating agencies are another set of entities with whom banks have relationships, as their ratings impact the bank's funding costs.

Table: Commercial Relationships in the Banking Value Chain

Value Chain Step Key Players Involved Nature of Commercial Relationship
Funding/Resource Gathering Banks, Individuals, SMEs, Corporations, Financial Institutions, Institutional Investors, Wholesale Market Participants Depositor-Bank (Deposit Agreements, Interest, Security), Bank-Investor (Debt Issuance Agreements), Interbank (Credit Line Agreements)
Financial Intermediation Banks, Individuals, SMEs, Corporations, Financial Institutions Lender-Borrower (Loan/Credit Agreements, Interest Payments), Interbank (Syndicated Loan Agreements)
Product & Service Development & Delivery Banks, Customers, Technology Providers, Fintech Companies, Payment Networks, ATM Operators, Call Centers Bank-Customer (Transactional, Service Agreements), Bank-Provider (Technology Contracts, Partnership Agreements, Service Contracts)
Relationship Management & Servicing Banks, Customers, Financial Advisors, CRM System Providers Bank-Customer (Service Agreements, Advisory Agreements), Bank-Provider (Software/Service Contracts)
Risk Management & Compliance Banks, CMF, Banco Central de Chile, External Auditors, Legal Firms, Credit Rating Agencies Bank-Regulator (Reporting, Compliance, Audits), Bank-Provider (Professional Service Agreements)

Products and Services Exchanged

The exchange of products and services forms the core of the banking value chain in Chile, enabling the flow of funds and the provision of financial solutions tailored to different needs and segments.

In the Funding/Resource Gathering stage, the primary "products" exchanged are financial instruments that represent a liability for the bank and an asset for the customer or investor. These include various types of deposits such as checking accounts, which offer transactional convenience and access to payment systems; savings accounts, designed for积累 funds with interest; and time deposits, which provide higher returns in exchange for locking up funds for a specified period. For corporate and institutional clients, certificates of deposit and other short-term debt instruments are also exchanged. In the wholesale markets, banks issue and exchange bonds and other debt securities to raise larger sums of capital from institutional investors.

Moving to Financial Intermediation/Transformation, the key products exchanged are loans and credit facilities. For individuals, this includes consumer loans for various personal needs, and mortgage loans for the purchase of real estate. SMEs access commercial loans, lines of credit, factoring services (selling accounts receivable for immediate cash), and leasing agreements to finance their operations, investments, and working capital. Large corporations utilize more complex forms of financing, including corporate loans, syndicated loans, and access to capital markets for issuing their own debt or equity. Banks also facilitate the exchange of investment products, offering access to mutual funds, stocks, bonds, and other securities, acting either as brokers or through proprietary products.

The Product and Service Development & Delivery stage encompasses a wide range of offerings that facilitate transactions and provide convenience. Payment instruments like debit cards and credit cards are exchanged, enabling electronic payments at points of sale and online. Banks provide essential payment processing services for businesses, allowing them to accept various forms of payment from their customers. Electronic funds transfers, both domestic and international, are key services exchanged. Foreign exchange services are provided for individuals and businesses engaging in international transactions. Treasury management services are offered to corporations to help them manage their cash flow and liquidity efficiently. Digital banking platforms and mobile applications themselves can be viewed as services, providing customers with remote access to their accounts and a suite of banking functionalities. Insurance products, often developed in partnership with insurance companies, are frequently exchanged through the banking channel.

In the Relationship Management & Servicing stage, the value exchanged is primarily in the form of intangible services that enhance the customer experience and provide financial guidance. This includes responsive customer support to address inquiries and resolve issues, efficient account management services, and personalized financial advisory. For high-net-worth individuals, private banking services involve sophisticated wealth management, investment planning, tax advice, and estate planning. For corporate clients, relationship managers provide tailored financial advice and support.

Within Risk Management & Compliance, the exchange is predominantly information-based and procedural. Banks provide detailed financial statements, risk exposure reports (credit risk, market risk, operational risk), and compliance documentation to regulatory authorities like the CMF and the Banco Central. In return, regulators provide guidelines, Circulars, and feedback from audits and inspections. Banks also exchange information with credit bureaus and other data providers for credit assessment purposes.

Table: Products and Services Exchanged

Value Chain Step Products Exchanged Services Exchanged
Funding/Resource Gathering Checking Accounts, Savings Accounts, Time Deposits, Certificates of Deposit, Bonds, Short-Term Debt Instruments Account Opening and Management, Deposit and Withdrawal Services, Online and Mobile Access to Accounts
Financial Intermediation Consumer Loans, Mortgage Loans, Commercial Loans, Lines of Credit, Factoring, Leasing, Investment Products (Mutual Funds, Stocks, Bonds) Credit Analysis and Assessment, Loan Origination and Servicing, Investment Advisory, Portfolio Management, Financial Structuring
Product & Service Development & Delivery Debit Cards, Credit Cards, Payment Instruments Payment Processing, Fund Transfers (Domestic and International), Foreign Exchange, Treasury Management, Online/Mobile Banking, ATM Access, Insurance Products
Relationship Management & Servicing N/A Customer Support, Account Inquiries and Maintenance, Financial Advisory, Wealth Management, Estate Planning, Issue Resolution
Risk Management & Compliance Financial Reports, Risk Exposure Data, Compliance Documentation Regulatory Reporting and Communication, Auditing and Compliance Checks, Risk Assessment and Mitigation Advice, Data Exchange with Credit Bureaus

Business Models

The business models adopted by banks in the Chilean value chain are primarily centered around traditional financial intermediation, complemented by increasingly important fee-based activities and driven by technological advancements. These models are adapted to the specific segments and the competitive and regulatory landscape.

The cornerstone business model for most banks in Chile is the Net Interest Margin (NIM) Model. This model is fundamental to the Funding/Resource Gathering and Financial Intermediation stages. Banks generate profit by borrowing funds at a lower interest rate (from depositors or wholesale markets) and lending these funds out at a higher interest rate. The difference between the interest earned on assets (loans, investments) and the interest paid on liabilities (deposits, borrowings) constitutes the net interest income, which is a major component of a bank's revenue. The success of this model relies on effectively managing interest rate risk and credit risk.

Alongside the NIM model, a significant portion of revenue is generated through a Fee-Based Model. This is particularly prominent in the Product and Service Development & Delivery and Relationship Management & Servicing stages. Banks charge fees for a wide variety of services, including account maintenance, transaction processing, ATM usage, credit card annual fees, loan origination, and various other banking operations. For corporate and investment banking, fees are generated from services like mergers and acquisitions advisory, debt and equity capital markets activities, and treasury services. Private banking relies heavily on fees for wealth management and financial advisory services, often calculated as a percentage of assets under management. The fee-based model helps diversify revenue streams and can be less sensitive to fluctuations in interest rates compared to the NIM model.

The accelerating pace of technological change and the regulatory push for Open Finance are driving the adoption of a Digital/Platform Model. This model focuses on delivering banking products and services through digital channels, including online banking portals and mobile applications, enhancing customer convenience and potentially reducing operational costs associated with physical branches. The Fintech Law and the Open Finance System are further enabling platform-based models, where banks can integrate with fintechs and other third-party providers to offer a wider range of services to customers, potentially participating in data sharing ecosystems with customer consent. This model emphasizes user experience, digital innovation, and scalability.

For specific segments like Corporate and Investment Banking and Private Banking, a Relationship-Based Model is crucial for success. While still incorporating NIM and fee-based components, this model emphasizes building deep, long-term relationships with clients based on trust, personalized service, and tailored financial solutions. The revenue is generated through a combination of interest income from financing activities and fees for complex advisory and wealth management services. The strength of the relationship can be a key differentiator in a competitive market.

An increasingly important, albeit indirectly revenue-generating, aspect is the adherence to a Compliance-Driven Model. The stringent regulatory environment in Chile, overseen by the CMF and the Banco Central, mandates significant investment in compliance infrastructure, processes, and personnel. While compliance is a cost center, adherence to regulations, such as Basel III capital requirements and anti-money laundering (AML) regulations, is essential for maintaining the bank's license to operate, ensuring stability, and avoiding hefty fines and reputational damage. The implementation of new regulations, like the standardized methodology for loan provisioning, further reinforces this model.

Table: Business Models Employed

Value Chain Step Primary Business Models Description
Funding/Resource Gathering Net Interest Margin (NIM) Model Profiting from the difference between interest earned on assets and interest paid on liabilities.
Financial Intermediation Net Interest Margin (NIM) Model Earning revenue from the spread between interest charged on loans/investments and the cost of funds.
Product & Service Development & Delivery Fee-Based Model, Digital/Platform Model Generating income through service charges and commissions; leveraging technology for efficient service delivery and potentially integrated offerings.
Relationship Management & Servicing Fee-Based Model, Relationship-Based Model Earning fees for services and building strong, personalized relationships with high-value clients for long-term engagement and revenue.
Risk Management & Compliance Compliance-Driven Model (Indirect Cost/Risk Mitigation) Investing in systems and processes to ensure adherence to regulations, avoid penalties, and maintain operational stability and trust.

Bottlenecks and Challenges

Despite the maturity and relative stability of the Chilean banking sector, several bottlenecks and challenges persist, impacting efficiency, competitiveness, and the ability to serve the entire population effectively. These challenges are influenced by both internal industry dynamics and external factors, including the evolving regulatory landscape and technological advancements.

A prominent bottleneck is the High Market Concentration. The Chilean banking industry is characterized by the significant market share held by a few large banks. This can limit healthy competition, potentially leading to less favorable terms and conditions for customers compared to more fragmented markets. For SMEs, this concentration can translate into limited access to financing options and less tailored products, as larger banks may prioritize larger corporate clients. While the presence of major players ensures stability, it can stifle innovation and reduce the incentive for banks to cater to niche segments.

The Evolving Regulatory Landscape and Compliance Burden represents a continuous challenge. The Chilean banking sector is subject to extensive regulation by the CMF and the Banco Central. While essential for financial stability, the ongoing implementation of international standards like Basel III, with its increased capital requirements, and the adaptation to new domestic laws such as the Fintech Law and regulations around the Open Finance System, demand significant investment in systems, processes, and specialized personnel. Meeting these evolving compliance requirements can be costly and time-consuming, potentially diverting resources from other strategic initiatives and creating a bottleneck in adopting new technologies or business models. The full implementation of Basel III requirements by December 2025 is a key focus.

Technological Adoption and Cybersecurity Risks pose a dual challenge. While banks are increasingly investing in digital transformation and mobile banking to enhance customer experience and operational efficiency, keeping pace with the rapid advancements in financial technology is difficult. Integrating legacy IT systems with newer digital solutions is a complex and costly undertaking. Furthermore, the increased reliance on digital channels and the implementation of data sharing through Open Finance heighten the importance of cybersecurity. Protecting customer data and preventing cyberattacks and fraud are critical challenges that require continuous investment and vigilance.

Financial Inclusion and Access to Credit for underserved segments, particularly SMEs, individuals with limited credit history, and vulnerable populations like migrants, remains a significant bottleneck. Traditional credit assessment methodologies often pose barriers for these groups, requiring collateral or extensive financial documentation that they may not possess. While initiatives exist to address this, bridging the gap in financial access and providing suitable products and services to these segments is an ongoing challenge for the industry.

Managing Credit and Operational Risks in a dynamic economic environment is a constant challenge. Banks are exposed to the risk of borrowers defaulting on loans, which can be exacerbated by economic downturns. Operational risks, such as system failures, fraud, and human error, can also lead to significant financial losses and reputational damage. The implementation of standardized methodologies for calculating loan loss provisions aims to enhance credit risk management, but it requires careful implementation by banks.

Increased Competition from Fintechs is a growing challenge to the traditional banking model. Enabled by the new Fintech Law, these agile companies are offering specialized financial services, often with a focus on digital delivery and specific customer needs. This competition can put pressure on banks' fee structures and market share in areas like payments, lending, and financial advisory. Banks face the challenge of adapting their strategies to either compete effectively with or collaborate with these new players.

Table: Bottlenecks and Challenges

Aspect of Value Chain Affected Bottleneck/Challenge Description
Overall Value Chain, Financial Intermediation, Product & Service Delivery Market Concentration Limited competition due to the dominance of a few large banks, potentially affecting pricing, innovation, and access to finance for certain segments.
All Stages Evolving Regulatory Landscape and Compliance Burden Significant investment and effort required to adapt to new regulations (Basel III, Fintech Law, Open Finance) and maintain ongoing compliance.
Product & Service Development & Delivery, Relationship Management & Servicing, Risk Management & Compliance Technological Adoption and Cybersecurity Risks Challenges in integrating new technologies with legacy systems and ensuring robust cybersecurity against evolving threats, especially with increased digitalization.
Financial Intermediation, Relationship Management & Servicing Financial Inclusion and Access to Credit Difficulties for SMEs, individuals with limited history, and vulnerable populations in accessing banking products and credit.
All Stages Managing Credit and Operational Risks The ongoing need to effectively identify, assess, and mitigate risks associated with lending and internal operations in a changing economic and technological environment.
Product & Service Development & Delivery, Business Models Increased Competition from Fintechs Pressure on traditional banking services and market share from agile, technology-focused financial service providers.

References

FO_paper.pdf](https://www.stephanygj.net/papers/CORFO_paper.pdf)