Skip to content

Value Chain Analysis of the Banking in Colombia.

Commercial Relationships

The banking value chain in Colombia is characterized by a complex web of commercial relationships among diverse players, fundamentally centered on the intermediation of funds. These relationships operate across distinct stages: Captación (Funding), Colocación (Lending), Gestión de Tesorería (Treasury Management), and Servicios Financieros Especializados (Specialized Financial Services).

In the Captación stage, the primary commercial relationships are between banks (such as Commercial Banks like Bancolombia, Banco Davivienda, and the subsidiaries of Grupo Aval: Banco de Bogota, Banco Popular, Banco de Occidente, Banco AV Villas) and various depositors. [Context] This includes direct relationships with millions of individual customers who open checking and savings accounts or purchase time deposits (CDTs and CDATs). [Context] Banks actively market deposit products through extensive branch networks, online platforms, and mobile applications to attract these retail funds. [Context] Similarly, banks establish relationships with businesses of all sizes, offering tailored deposit and cash management solutions that facilitate efficient handling of corporate liquidity. Large institutional clients, such as other financial institutions, pension funds, and government entities, also maintain substantial deposit relationships with banks, often involving negotiated terms and specialized services. Beyond direct deposits, banks engage in commercial relationships in financial markets to raise wholesale funding. This involves issuing debt instruments like bonds to institutional investors or engaging in interbank borrowing and lending with other financial institutions to manage short-term liquidity needs. [Context] The Central Bank (Banco de la República) is another crucial entity, interacting with banks through monetary policy tools, including setting reserve requirements and conducting open market operations that influence banks' funding costs and liquidity. [Context]

The Colocación stage reverses the flow of funds, establishing commercial relationships between banks and borrowers. Commercial Banks are the dominant players, providing credit across multiple segments. [Context] In retail lending, banks offer personal loans, auto loans, student loans, and credit cards directly to individual consumers, assessing their creditworthiness and managing repayment processes. [Context] Commercial lending involves relationships with businesses, ranging from small enterprises to large corporations. Banks provide working capital loans, term loans for investment, and trade finance, often requiring detailed financial analysis and ongoing relationship management. [Context] Mortgage lending involves long-term relationships with individuals and businesses for property financing, requiring specialized processes for property valuation and loan servicing. [Context] Microcredit focuses on providing small loans to microenterprises and individuals in the popular economy, often involving non-traditional credit assessment methods and financial education support. [Context] Specialized entities like Finance Companies and Financial Corporations also maintain commercial relationships with businesses for targeted financing, while Development Banks like Bancóldex and Finagro partner with businesses and sometimes commercial banks to channel funds towards specific economic sectors or development objectives. [Context] Cooperative Financial Institutions serve their members with credit. The government, through initiatives led by entities like Minhacienda, seeks to establish relationships that encourage banks to extend credit to underserved populations for financial inclusion purposes. [Context]

Gestión de Tesorería, while largely an internal function, involves significant external commercial interactions, primarily in financial markets and with the Central Bank. Banks' treasury departments interact with other banks in the interbank market, lending or borrowing short-term funds to manage daily liquidity positions. They participate in the foreign exchange market, trading currencies with other financial institutions and the Central Bank, often using instruments like spot contracts and NDFs. [Context] Trading desks within banks also maintain commercial relationships with brokerage houses and institutional investors to buy and sell government securities (TES) and other financial instruments as part of their investment and risk management strategies. [Context] Asset and Liability Management (ALM) involves managing the balance sheet composition, which indirectly relies on the success of commercial relationships in both Captación and Colocación to ensure a stable and profitable funding structure. [Context]

Finally, Servicios Financieros Especializados encompass a wide range of commercial relationships. Fiduciary Societies, such as Fiduciaria Bancolombia, establish fiduciary contracts with individuals, companies, and government entities (settlors) to manage assets or resources on their behalf, acting for the benefit of designated beneficiaries. [Context] Investment Banking divisions or firms within or affiliated with banks (like those under Grupo Aval through Corficolombiana) form relationships with corporations and governments needing assistance with capital raising (issuing stocks or bonds), mergers and acquisitions (M&A) advisory, or project finance structuring. [Context] Wealth Management services involve close advisory relationships between bank wealth managers and high-net-worth individuals and families, providing personalized financial planning and investment management. Brokerage Houses like Valores Bancolombia engage in commercial relationships with clients to execute trades on stock exchanges. Pension Fund Administrators (AFPs) like Porvenir manage funds contributed by employers and employees, establishing relationships with asset managers and brokerage houses to invest these funds. [Context] Leasing and Factoring companies create relationships with businesses seeking alternative financing for assets or needing to convert receivables into immediate cash. Digital Banking and Fintech players establish direct relationships with customers through digital channels, offering services via mobile apps and online platforms, often bypassing traditional physical touchpoints. [Context] These Fintechs may also form B2B relationships with traditional banks, providing technology solutions or access to new customer segments.

Overall, the commercial relationships in the Colombian banking value chain are multi-faceted, extending from direct customer interactions for deposits and loans to sophisticated market transactions and specialized service provision, all underpinned by the flow of capital and financial instruments.

Products and Services Exchanged

The commercial relationships within the Colombian banking value chain are built upon the exchange of a diverse array of financial products and services, tailored to meet the needs of various customer segments and market demands.

In the Captación stage, the primary products and services exchanged involve the collection of funds from the public and institutions. These include standard deposit products offered to retail customers, such as checking accounts (cuenta corriente bancaria) which facilitate frequent transactions and payments, and savings accounts (cuenta de ahorros) designed for accumulating funds, often with varying interest rates and liquidity features. [Context] Time deposits, prominently represented by Certificates of Deposit (CDT) and Certificates of Deposit of Administration (CDAT), are exchanged for funds committed for a fixed period, offering typically higher interest rates based on the term and amount. [Context] For corporate and institutional clients, banks offer specialized current and savings accounts along with comprehensive cash management services that include collections, payments, and liquidity pooling solutions. [Context] In the market funding segment, banks exchange newly issued debt instruments, such as corporate bonds or commercial paper, for capital from institutional investors, or engage in the exchange of funds in the interbank market, essentially short-term loans and deposits between financial institutions. [Context]

In the Colocación stage, banks exchange funds for borrowers' commitments to repay, often with interest and fees. Retail lending products include personal loans for various purposes, auto loans for vehicle purchases, student loans, and credit cards that provide revolving credit facilities. [Context] Businesses access commercial loans, which can be short-term working capital loans to finance daily operations, term loans for long-term investments in assets or expansion, and trade finance products like letters of credit or guarantees to support international or domestic trade activities. [Context] Mortgage loans are exchanged for the right to place a lien on a property, providing long-term financing for residential or commercial real estate acquisition or development. [Context] Microcredit involves the exchange of small loan amounts, often with flexible terms, for the borrower's promise to use the funds for productive economic activities and repay the principal and interest. [Context] Development banks exchange specialized credit lines, often with favorable terms or guarantees, for commitments from businesses in targeted sectors like agriculture or specific development projects. [Context]

Gestión de Tesorería involves the exchange of financial instruments and funds within the financial markets and with the central bank. Banks exchange short-term funds in the interbank market through unsecured loans and deposits or secured transactions like repurchase agreements (repos), where securities are exchanged for cash with an agreement to repurchase them later. [Context] They trade government securities (TES) with the Central Bank and other market participants, exchanging cash for bonds or vice versa. [Context] Foreign exchange services involve exchanging one currency for another, either immediately (spot transactions) or at a future date at a predetermined rate (forward contracts, including NDFs). [Context] Banks also use and exchange complex derivative instruments like interest rate swaps to manage their exposure to interest rate fluctuations. [Context]

Servicios Financieros Especializados offer a broader spectrum of exchanges. Fiduciary services involve the exchange of control and management of assets (money, property, securities) from the settlor to the fiduciary society under a contract (fiducia mercantil or encargo fiduciario) in exchange for the fiduciary's commitment to manage these assets for a specific purpose and benefit a beneficiary. [Context] Investment banking services involve the exchange of advisory expertise and underwriting services for fees paid by corporations or governments seeking to raise capital or execute strategic transactions like M&A. [Context] Wealth management exchanges financial planning advice and portfolio management services for fees or a percentage of assets under management from high-net-worth clients. Brokerage services exchange the execution of buy and sell orders for securities on behalf of clients for commissions. [Context] Pension fund management involves the exchange of regular contributions from employers and employees for the administrator's service of managing these funds and providing future pension benefits. [Context] Leasing involves the exchange of the right to use an asset for regular lease payments, while factoring involves the exchange of accounts receivable (future payment rights) for immediate cash at a discount. Digital banking platforms facilitate the exchange of funds through electronic payments (P2P, bill payments), offer digital account opening and management, and enable online applications for various banking products, exchanging convenience and speed for customer engagement and transaction volume. [Context]

These diverse products and services form the core of the Colombian banking value chain, enabling the flow of capital, facilitating economic activity, and providing a range of financial solutions to individuals and businesses.

Business Models

The Colombian banking industry employs several interconnected business models to generate revenue, manage risk, and deliver value across its value chain.

The most fundamental and prevalent business model is the Traditional Financial Intermediation Model, often referred to as the "interest rate spread" or "net interest margin" model. This model is central to the Captación and Colocación stages. Banks profitability stems from attracting deposits (Captación) at a certain interest rate (cost of funding) and then lending out those funds (Colocación) at a higher interest rate (return on assets). [Context] The difference between the interest earned on loans and investments and the interest paid on deposits and borrowings constitutes the net interest income, which is the primary revenue driver for commercial banks and other credit institutions. [Context] Successful execution of this model relies on effectively managing interest rate risk, credit risk (default risk on loans), and liquidity risk. Players like Bancolombia, Grupo Aval's subsidiary banks (Banco de Bogota, Banco Popular, Banco de Occidente, Banco AV Villas), and Banco Davivienda heavily rely on this model due to their large deposit bases and extensive loan portfolios. [Context]

Complementary to the interest spread model is the Fee and Commission-Based Services Model. Banks increasingly generate revenue from non-interest income, which includes fees charged for various services. These fees arise from transaction processing (e.g., ATM withdrawals, transfers, bill payments), account maintenance, credit card services, foreign exchange transactions, and commissions from selling or distributing insurance and investment products. This model is particularly significant in the Servicios Financieros Especializados stage. Fiduciary societies earn fees for managing trusts based on the value of assets or the complexity of the mandate. [Context] Investment banking divisions charge fees for advisory services on M&A, underwriting securities, and structuring deals. Wealth management services generate fees based on assets under management or performance fees. Brokerage houses earn commissions on securities trades executed for clients. [Context] This model helps diversify revenue streams and can be less sensitive to interest rate fluctuations than the traditional spread model.

Specialized institutions often employ variations of these models or focus on specific niches. Finance Companies and Financial Corporations operate with a focused lending model, targeting specific sectors like consumer finance or corporate development, sometimes allowing for potentially higher risk-adjusted returns on their specialized portfolios. [Context] Development Banks operate with a public policy model, where the objective is not solely profit maximization but also promoting economic development in specific sectors or regions through targeted credit programs, often with government support or funding. [Context]

The rise of technology has led to the development and adoption of the Digital Banking/Fintech Model. This model leverages digital channels (mobile apps, online platforms) to deliver financial services, aiming to improve efficiency, reduce operational costs (e.g., fewer physical branches), enhance customer experience, and expand reach, particularly to the unbanked or underbanked population. [Context] Players like Banco Davivienda, with its successful Daviplata platform, demonstrate this model by providing accessible low-amount deposits and digital payment services, generating revenue through transaction volume and potential cross-selling. [Context] Traditional banks are increasingly integrating digital capabilities into their existing models to remain competitive.

Finally, the Holding Company Model, exemplified by Grupo Aval, involves generating value through the strategic management and synergy of multiple financial entities operating across different segments of the value chain (banking, pensions, merchant banking). [Context] This allows for diversified income streams, shared resources, and the potential for cross-selling products and services across the group's extensive customer base. [Context]

In practice, most large commercial banks in Colombia utilize a hybrid model, combining the traditional interest rate spread model with a growing emphasis on fee-based services and significant investment in digital channels to serve a broad spectrum of clients and diversify their revenue sources.

Bottlenecks and Challenges

The Colombian banking value chain, while robust, faces several significant bottlenecks and challenges that impact its efficiency, profitability, and ability to serve the entire population.

A major challenge lies in the deterioration of credit quality and the increase in delinquency rates. [Context] Reports indicate a rise in non-performing loans, with more Colombians struggling to meet their debt obligations. [Context, Context] This directly affects the Colocación stage, requiring banks to increase provisions for potential loan losses, which in turn reduces profitability. This bottleneck is particularly acute in retail and SME lending segments, where borrowers may be more vulnerable to economic fluctuations.

Related to credit quality is the slowdown in credit growth. While projections for 2025 show anticipated growth, the credit portfolio experienced negative real annual growth from mid-2022. [Context] This impacts the volume of business in the Colocación step, limiting the potential for interest income generation, the core of the traditional banking model. Economic uncertainty and high-interest rates have contributed to reduced demand for new loans and a more cautious approach from both lenders and borrowers. [Context]

Profitability pressures are a significant challenge across the value chain. While some major banks reported profits in 2024, others faced losses, and industry-wide profits saw a dip before a slight recovery. [Context] This indicates a challenging operating environment, potentially due to the aforementioned credit risk issues requiring higher provisions, increased funding costs in the Captación stage due to monetary policy, or compressed net interest margins. Maintaining healthy returns on equity in this environment is a key bottleneck.

Macroeconomic headwinds such as inflation and elevated interest rates set by the Central Bank directly impact multiple stages. High interest rates increase the cost of funding for banks (Captación), make borrowing more expensive for customers (Colocación), potentially increasing credit risk, and can dampen overall economic activity, affecting demand for financial services. [Context, Context]

The need for continuous digital transformation is both an opportunity and a challenge. While digital channels like Daviplata have successfully expanded financial inclusion and transaction volumes in the Captación and Servicios Financieros Especializados (Digital Banking) segments, banks face significant investment requirements to upgrade their technology infrastructure, enhance cybersecurity, and develop user-friendly digital platforms to meet evolving customer expectations and compete with agile Fintech companies. [Context, Context] The rapid pace of technological change necessitates constant adaptation and investment.

Addressing the financial inclusion gap remains a persistent challenge. Despite efforts to reach unbanked and underbanked populations through initiatives like SEDPEs and microcredit programs, a significant portion of the Colombian population still lacks access to formal financial services. [Context, Context] Reaching these segments requires tailored products, accessible infrastructure (including digital), and financial education, which can be challenging and costly to implement on a large scale.

The regulatory and compliance burden is substantial for the banking sector. The complex framework of regulations overseen by entities like the Superintendencia Financiera requires significant resources for compliance, reporting, and risk management. [Context, Context] Adapting to new regulations and ensuring adherence adds to operational complexity and costs.

Finally, reengineering customer service is identified as a top challenge for 2025. [Context] Meeting customer demands for seamless, personalized, and efficient service across both digital and traditional channels requires significant investment in training, technology, and process improvement. Failure to deliver excellent customer service can lead to customer attrition and damage brand reputation, impacting relationships in all value chain stages.

These bottlenecks and challenges highlight the dynamic and sometimes difficult operating environment for the Colombian banking industry, requiring strategic adaptation and ongoing efforts to manage risks, enhance efficiency, and expand reach.

References