Value Chain Report on the Energy Industry in Colombia

Abstract

This report provides a comprehensive analysis of the energy industry value chain in Colombia, encompassing both the hydrocarbons (oil and natural gas) and electricity sectors. It details the sequential stages from exploration and production/generation through midstream transportation/transmission, downstream processing/generation, and final distribution and commercialization. The analysis profiles key players, such as the state-controlled Ecopetrol which dominates the hydrocarbon sector, and significant entities like Grupo Empresarial EPM, Organización Terpel, Celsia, and ISA in the electricity and fuel distribution markets. Commercial relationships are explored, highlighting the mix of regulated tariffs, long-term contracts (e.g., PPAs), wholesale market transactions (MEM), and retail sales models. The report identifies critical bottlenecks and challenges, including declining hydrocarbon reserves, infrastructure security risks, transmission grid limitations for renewables, high distribution losses in certain regions, regulatory complexities, social-environmental hurdles, and the overarching challenges of the energy transition. The business models employed across the value chain, ranging from resource extraction and regulated utilities to service provision and retail margin models, are also examined.

Introduction

The energy sector is a cornerstone of Colombia's economy, encompassing a diverse mix of resources and activities crucial for national development, industrial operations, and public welfare. Primarily structured around hydrocarbons (crude oil and natural gas) and electricity, the Colombian energy landscape involves a complex interplay of state-owned enterprises, private companies, and international players operating across a multi-stage value chain. The hydrocarbon segment, historically dominant, involves exploration, extraction, transportation, refining, and distribution, with Ecopetrol S.A., the state-controlled entity, playing a pivotal role. The electricity sector relies heavily on hydropower, complemented by thermal generation and increasingly, non-conventional renewable sources like solar and wind. This sector involves generation, high-voltage transmission, regional distribution, and commercialization to end-users, with significant players including public utility groups like Grupo Empresarial EPM, generation companies like Celsia, and transmission specialists like ISA.

The purpose of this report is to provide a detailed and granular analysis of the energy value chain in Colombia. It aims to meticulously define each step and segment, identify the key actors and their respective roles and sizes, delineate the commercial relationships and business models governing interactions between these players, and critically examine the principal bottlenecks and challenges hindering the sector's efficiency, security, and sustainable development. The scope covers both the hydrocarbon and electricity value chains, offering a comprehensive overview suitable for industry stakeholders, policymakers, investors, and researchers seeking in-depth knowledge of the Colombian energy sector's structure, dynamics, and critical issues.

Value Chain Definition

The energy industry value chain in Colombia represents the complete lifecycle of energy resources, from initial discovery and extraction to final delivery and consumption. It can be conceptualized into distinct stages, each with specific segments and activities, differing slightly between the hydrocarbon and electricity sub-sectors.

The primary steps identified are:

1. Exploration and Production (E&P) / Primary Resource Acquisition: This foundational stage involves locating and accessing primary energy sources.
   • Hydrocarbons: Focuses on discovering potential subterranean deposits of crude oil and natural gas through geological and geophysical surveys, followed by drilling wells and extracting the raw resources.
   • Electricity: Relates to securing the inputs for generation: water rights and reservoir management for hydroelectric plants, fuel procurement (natural gas, coal, liquids) for thermal plants, land acquisition and resource assessment (solar irradiance, wind patterns) for renewable facilities.
2. Midstream (Hydrocarbons) / Transmission (Electricity): This stage concerns the bulk transportation of energy from the source or generation point towards processing centers or load centers.
   • Hydrocarbons: Encompasses the movement of crude oil, natural gas, and Natural Gas Liquids (NGLs) via extensive pipeline networks, oil tankers, barges, and trucks. It also includes associated storage in tank farms or underground facilities and preliminary processing like gas conditioning.
   • Electricity: Involves the high-voltage transmission of electrical power generated at power plants through the national transmission grid (Sistema de Transmisión Nacional - STN) to regional substations where voltage is stepped down for distribution.
3. Downstream (Hydrocarbons) / Generation (Electricity): This stage involves transforming raw resources into usable energy forms or processing them into intermediate products.
   • Hydrocarbons: Primarily includes refining crude oil into marketable fuels (gasoline, diesel, jet fuel, LPG), lubricants, and asphalt, as well as processing natural gas to remove impurities and separate NGLs. This stage also includes the petrochemical industry, which uses hydrocarbon feedstocks.
   • Electricity: This is the core process of converting primary energy sources (hydro potential, thermal fuels, solar radiation, wind kinetic energy, geothermal heat, biomass) into electrical energy in power plants.
4. Distribution and Commercialization: The final stage focuses on delivering energy to end-users and managing the associated commercial activities.
   • Hydrocarbons: Involves distributing refined fuels to retail stations or large consumers, and distributing natural gas through local pipeline networks to residential, commercial, and industrial customers.
   • Electricity: Encompasses the distribution of electricity from regional substations through medium and low-voltage networks (Sistema de Distribución Local - SDL) to final consumers. Commercialization involves the retail aspect: selling energy, metering, billing, customer service, and managing energy contracts.

Detailed Segments and Activities

• Exploration and Production (E&P):
  • Segments: Exploration (Geological & Geophysical Studies, Seismic Acquisition & Processing, Exploratory Drilling), Production/Development (Development Drilling, Well Completion & Stimulation, Fluid Lifting, Field Processing, Reservoir Management).
  • Main Activities: Conducting geological surveys, interpreting seismic data, securing exploration licenses, drilling exploration and production wells, installing surface facilities, operating wells and separation units, managing water and gas injection for enhanced recovery.
• Midstream (Hydrocarbons) / Transmission (Electricity):
  • Segments: Transportation (Pipeline Operations, Marine & Road Logistics, Terminal Operations), Storage (Tank Farms, Underground Gas Storage), Basic Processing (Gas Conditioning, Crude Stabilization), High-Voltage Transmission (Grid Operation, Substation Management, System Stability).
  • Main Activities: Operating and maintaining pipelines and pumping/compressor stations, managing tanker schedules and loading/unloading operations, operating storage facilities, performing basic treatment to meet transport specifications, operating high-voltage lines and substations, managing power flow and grid frequency/voltage.
• Downstream (Hydrocarbons) / Generation (Electricity):
  • Segments: Refining (Crude Distillation, Conversion Processes, Blending), Petrochemicals (Basic Chemicals Production), Gas Processing (Gas Purification, NGL Fractionation), Power Generation (Hydroelectric Operations, Thermal Plant Operations, Renewable Plant Operations - Solar/Wind).
  • Main Activities: Operating complex refinery units (distillation towers, crackers, reformers), managing catalyst systems, producing fuels to specification, operating chemical reactors, running gas treatment plants and NGL facilities, operating turbines and generators, managing water reservoirs, managing fuel supply and logistics for thermal plants, operating and maintaining solar panels/wind turbines, dispatching power according to grid operator instructions.
• Distribution and Commercialization:
  • Segments: Distribution Networks (Gas Pipelines, Electricity Lines & Transformers - Medium/Low Voltage), Retail/Commercialization (Energy Sales, Billing & Collection, Customer Service, Metering).
  • Main Activities: Operating and maintaining local gas pipes and electrical lines/transformers, managing pressure/voltage regulation, connecting new customers, installing and reading meters, managing energy procurement (for commercializers), setting tariffs (within regulatory frameworks), issuing bills, managing customer accounts and inquiries, marketing energy plans (especially to non-regulated users).

Players Analysis

The Colombian energy value chain is populated by a diverse set of players, ranging from large state-controlled entities to multinational corporations and specialized domestic firms. Their roles, activities, and scale vary significantly depending on the segment they operate in.

Types of Players by Segment:

• Exploration and Production (E&P):
  • National Oil Company (NOC): Ecopetrol S.A.
  • International Oil Companies (IOCs): Multinational corporations with exploration and production licenses.
  • Independent E&P Companies: Smaller domestic or foreign companies focused solely on E&P.
• Midstream (Hydrocarbons) / Transmission (Electricity):
  • Integrated Companies: Ecopetrol (significant pipeline ownership/operation).
  • Pipeline Operators: Specialized companies managing specific pipeline assets.
  • Storage Companies: Firms providing hydrocarbon storage services.
  • Energy Infrastructure Companies: Firms investing in and operating midstream assets.
  • National Transmission System Operator (TSO): ISA (Interconexión Eléctrica S.A. E.S.P.) is the dominant player in high-voltage electricity transmission.
• Downstream (Hydrocarbons) / Generation (Electricity):
  • Integrated NOC: Ecopetrol (operates major refineries and gas processing).
  • Refining Companies: Primarily Ecopetrol.
  • Petrochemical Companies: Ecopetrol and other specialized chemical firms.
  • Gas Processing Companies: Ecopetrol and potentially others.
  • Power Generation Companies: Large public utilities (EPM), private companies (Celsia), specialized thermal operators (Tebsa), Independent Power Producers (IPPs), growing number of renewable energy developers.
• Distribution and Commercialization:
  • Natural Gas Distribution Companies: Vanti S.A. E.S.P., EPM (through subsidiaries), others serving specific regions.
  • Electricity Distribution Companies: Grupo Empresarial EPM (including Afinia), Air-e, Celsia (in specific regions), other regional distributors.
  • Energy Commercialization Companies: Often integrated with distribution (EPM, Air-e, Afinia, Celsia), fuel specialists (Organización Terpel, Biomax Biocombustibles), independent energy retailers serving non-regulated clients.

Key Player Profiles:

• Ecopetrol S.A.: The largest company in Colombia by revenue (COP 133.3 trillion in 2024), Ecopetrol is the state-controlled, integrated energy giant. It overwhelmingly dominates the hydrocarbon sector, responsible for the majority of the nation's oil and gas production (e.g., 60% of crude, 70% of gas in Oct 2024), extensive midstream pipeline operations (transporting 1,113 k bpd in 2023), and nearly all domestic refining capacity. Ecopetrol is actively pursuing energy transition initiatives, investing in areas like green hydrogen and carbon capture, while navigating policies regarding exploration methods like fracking. Its production reached 746 kboed in 2024.
• Grupo Empresarial EPM (Empresas Públicas de Medellín): A major publicly owned multi-utility group headquartered in Medellín. EPM is a dominant force in the electricity sector, particularly in distribution and commercialization, where its segment revenue reached COP 26 trillion in 2023, making it the largest distributor nationally. It also has significant generation assets, including a major stake in the large Hidroituango hydroelectric project, and operates transmission infrastructure. Through subsidiaries like Afinia (serving the Caribbean region), its reach extends across Colombia. Total group revenue was COP 37.5 trillion in 2023.
• Organización Terpel S.A.: A leading player in the downstream fuel market, Terpel specializes in the commercialization and distribution of liquid fuels and lubricants through an extensive network of service stations. It is also involved in natural gas distribution. With revenues of COP 33.94 trillion in 2024, it is one of Colombia's largest companies, heavily focused on the retail fuel segment and adapting to trends like electric mobility charging infrastructure.
• Celsia S.A. E.S.P.: Part of the Grupo Argos conglomerate, Celsia operates across electricity generation, transmission, and commercialization. Historically strong in hydroelectric generation (95% of its portfolio in 2022), Celsia is aggressively expanding its renewable energy footprint, notably through the acquisition of 675 MW of solar and wind projects. This positions Celsia as a key driver of Colombia's renewable energy transition. Its revenue was COP 6,229.9 billion (approx. 6.2 trillion) in 2023.
• ISA (Interconexión Eléctrica S.A. E.S.P.): The primary operator of Colombia's high-voltage electricity transmission system (STN). ISA connects power generation plants to distribution networks across the country, playing a critical role in grid stability and power delivery. As a regulated entity, it operates critical infrastructure ensuring bulk power movement. Its revenue (Interconexión Eléctrica unit) was COP 3.7 trillion in 2023.
• Air-e & Afinia: These two companies emerged from the restructuring of Electricaribe and are responsible for electricity distribution and commercialization in the challenging Caribbean coastal region. Air-e reported revenues of COP 6.1 trillion in 2023, while Afinia (an EPM subsidiary) reported COP 5.9 trillion in 2023. They face significant tasks in improving infrastructure and reducing energy losses.
• Vanti S.A. E.S.P.: A major player focused on the distribution and commercialization of natural gas, serving a large customer base primarily in Bogotá and surrounding areas. Its revenue was COP 3.8 trillion in 2023.
• Biomax Biocombustibles S.A.: A significant distributor and commercializer of liquid fuels, competing with Terpel in the downstream market. Its revenue was COP 3.7 trillion in 2023.
• Tebsa (Termobarranquilla S.A. E.S.P.): Operates one of the country's largest thermal power plants, providing crucial backup and firm energy capacity, particularly important during dry seasons when hydroelectric output diminishes.

Value Chain Summary Table and Volume Estimates

The following table summarizes the value chain structure, key players, activities, and available size estimates:

Value Chain Step	Segments	Types of Players	Main Activities	Examples of Key Players	Estimates of Volumes/Sizes
Exploration & Production	Exploration, Production	NOCs, IOCs, Independent E&P companies	Geological surveys, exploratory drilling, well completion, extraction of hydrocarbons, primary processing.	Ecopetrol	Ecopetrol: 746 kboed (2024 total prod), 461 k b/d crude (Oct 2024, 60% national), 974 Mf3/d gas (Oct 2024, 70% national).
Midstream (Hydrocarbons)	Transportation, Storage, Processing	Pipeline operators, Storage companies, Energy infrastructure companies	Operating and maintaining pipelines, managing storage, preliminary hydrocarbon processing.	Ecopetrol, Organización Terpel	Ecopetrol: Transported 1,113 thousand bpd (2023). Volumes for Terpel's midstream activities not provided.
Transmission (Electricity)	High-Voltage Transmission	National Transmission System Operator (TSO), Energy infrastructure companies	Operating and maintaining high-voltage lines, managing grid stability.	ISA	Specific volumes (GWh transmitted) not provided. ISA (Interconexión Eléctrica) Revenue: COP 3.7T (2023).
Downstream (Hydrocarbons)	Refining, Petrochemicals, Gas Processing	Refining companies, Petrochemical companies, Gas processing companies	Operating refineries, chemical plants, gas processing facilities.	Ecopetrol	Specific volumes for refining or processing not provided. Ecopetrol Total Revenue (integrated): COP 133.3T (2024).
Generation (Electricity)	Power Generation (Hydro, Thermal, Solar, Wind)	Power generation companies (utility-scale), IPPs	Operating power plants, managing fuel supply, maintenance, dispatching electricity.	Celsia, Grupo Empresarial EPM, Tebsa	Celsia: Significant hydraulic capacity (95% in 2022), acquired 675 MW solar/wind projects. Revenue: COP 6.2T (2023). Specific generation volumes not provided.
Distribution (Energy)	Natural Gas Distribution, Electricity Distribution	Natural gas distribution companies, Electricity distribution companies	Operating and maintaining local distribution networks, connecting customers, meter reading.	Grupo Empresarial EPM, Air-e, Afinia, Vanti	Specific volumes (GWh/m³ distributed) not provided. Revenues indicate size (EPM Dist/Comm: COP 26T 2023; Air-e: COP 6.1T 2023; Afinia: COP 5.9T 2023; Vanti: COP 3.8T 2023).
Commercialization (Energy)	Energy Commercialization	Energy commercialization companies (retail), Distribution companies (often integrated)	Selling energy, billing, customer service, managing contracts.	Organización Terpel, Grupo Empresarial EPM, Air-e, Afinia, Vanti, Biomax Biocombustibles	Specific volumes of energy sold not provided. Revenues indicate size (Terpel: COP 33.9T 2024; EPM Dist/Comm: COP 26T 2023; Air-e: COP 6.1T 2023; Afinia: COP 5.9T 2023; Vanti: COP 3.8T 2023; Biomax: COP 3.7T 2023).

The scale of the industry is significant, highlighted by Ecopetrol's massive production and transportation volumes and the substantial revenues generated by players across the electricity distribution and fuel commercialization segments.

Commercial Relationships

Commercial interactions within Colombia's energy value chain are diverse, governed by a combination of regulated frameworks, long-term contractual agreements, and market-based transactions. These relationships define how value is exchanged between players at different stages.

• E&P to Midstream/Downstream (Hydrocarbons): E&P companies sell crude oil and natural gas. Integrated players like Ecopetrol may internally transfer resources, while independent producers sell to Ecopetrol, refiners, or midstream operators. Oil sales are often priced based on international benchmarks (e.g., Brent) adjusted for quality and transport. Gas sales occur under negotiated contracts or regulated frameworks, depending on the market segment (e.g., residential vs. industrial vs. thermal power).
• Midstream Services (Hydrocarbons): Midstream companies (including Ecopetrol's transport divisions) provide transportation and storage services. They charge E&P companies, refiners, or large consumers based on tariffs, typically regulated for major pipelines, calculated per volume transported or stored. Long-term "ship-or-pay" contracts are common, guaranteeing revenue for the operator and capacity for the shipper.
• Crude to Refining (Hydrocarbons): Refiners (mainly Ecopetrol) purchase crude oil feedstock from E&P entities (including their own production). This involves bulk transactions based on agreed pricing formulas linked to international crude prices.
• Refining to Distribution/Commercialization (Hydrocarbons): Refined products (gasoline, diesel, etc.) are sold wholesale by refiners to large distributors and commercializers like Terpel and Biomax. These sales occur under supply agreements specifying volumes, quality, delivery logistics, and pricing often tied to international product benchmarks plus margins.
• Generation to Transmission/Market (Electricity): Generators sell electricity primarily via two channels:
  • Wholesale Energy Market (MEM): Selling power on the spot market where prices fluctuate based on supply/demand, hydro levels, and fuel costs.
  • Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs): Long-term bilateral contracts with commercializers or large consumers, providing price stability and guaranteed offtake, crucial for financing new generation projects, especially renewables. Generators also participate in reliability charge auctions, establishing a commercial relationship with the system for providing firm capacity.
• Transmission Services (Electricity): Transmission companies like ISA charge regulated tariffs to generators and distribution companies for using the high-voltage grid. These CREG-approved tariffs cover the cost of service, including investment return, operations, and maintenance.
• Transmission to Distribution (Electricity): Distribution companies pay transmission tariffs for the bulk electricity received at regional substations.
• Distribution Services (Electricity & Gas): Distribution companies charge end-consumers regulated tariffs for the use of the local distribution network (poles, wires, transformers; local gas pipelines). These tariffs, set by CREG, bundle costs from generation, transmission, distribution, commercialization, losses, and taxes.
• Commercialization to End-Users (Electricity & Gas): Commercialization companies buy energy wholesale (from generators/MEM/processors) and sell it retail.
  • Regulated Market: Residential and small commercial users pay regulated tariffs covering the full energy service cost, with the commercializer earning a regulated margin.
  • Non-Regulated Market: Large industrial and commercial users negotiate contract terms (price, volume, duration) directly with commercializers, allowing for more tailored energy solutions and pricing. Fuel commercializers like Terpel operate retail stations, selling directly to consumers at posted prices, which include fuel costs, taxes, and distribution/retail margins.

Bottlenecks and Challenges

The Colombian energy value chain, while functional, faces numerous bottlenecks and challenges that impede efficiency, investment, and sustainability:

• Hydrocarbon Reserve Replacement: Declining production from mature oil and gas fields and difficulties in discovering and developing new reserves pose a long-term supply risk. Social, environmental, and political hurdles (e.g., debates around fracking) complicate exploration efforts.
• Infrastructure Security and Integrity (Hydrocarbons): Pipelines and related infrastructure are susceptible to security threats like illegal tapping (theft) and sabotage, leading to spills, supply disruptions, safety hazards, and significant economic losses. Maintaining integrity and ensuring security requires constant vigilance and investment.
• Midstream Capacity Constraints (Hydrocarbons & Electricity): While Ecopetrol manages large transport volumes, bottlenecks can occur in specific pipeline segments. More critically, electricity transmission infrastructure struggles to keep pace with the rapid development of new (especially renewable) generation capacity, particularly in resource-rich but remote areas like La Guajira. Delays in building new lines due to permitting, social consultation, and environmental licensing are a major impediment to evacuating renewable power.
• Electricity Distribution Losses: Particularly in regions like the Caribbean coast, distribution companies (Air-e, Afinia) grapple with high levels of both technical losses (due to aging or inefficient infrastructure) and non-technical losses (electricity theft, meter tampering, billing fraud). These losses inflate costs for paying customers and strain the financial health of the distributors, requiring massive investment and socio-political intervention.
• Regulatory Uncertainty and Policy Shifts: Changes in government administrations can bring shifts in energy policy priorities (e.g., emphasis on renewables vs. fossil fuels, tariff adjustments, subsidy policies). Regulatory complexity and occasional ambiguity can create uncertainty for investors, potentially delaying crucial long-term investments in generation, transmission, and distribution infrastructure. Striking a balance between affordable tariffs and cost recovery for utilities is an ongoing regulatory challenge.
• Social License to Operate and Environmental Concerns: Gaining community acceptance and navigating environmental regulations for new energy projects (E&P wells, pipelines, transmission lines, hydro dams, wind/solar farms) is increasingly complex and time-consuming. Opposition from local communities and environmental groups can lead to significant project delays, cost overruns, or cancellations.
• Energy Transition Management: Integrating large volumes of variable renewable energy (VRE) like solar and wind requires significant grid modernization, investment in flexibility solutions (e.g., battery storage, flexible thermal plants, demand-side management), and updated market mechanisms. Phasing down reliance on fossil fuels while ensuring energy security and managing the socio-economic impacts on dependent regions and workforces presents a complex long-term challenge.
• Access to Capital: While large established players have strong financing capabilities, securing capital for major infrastructure projects or innovative energy transition technologies can be challenging, especially for smaller companies or projects perceived as having higher risks (regulatory, social, or technical).

Value Chain Relationships and Business Models

This section delves deeper into the interplay of products, services, business models, and the challenges impacting transactions along the Colombian energy value chain.

Products and Services Exchanged

The flow along the value chain involves a transformation and exchange of tangible products and essential services: * Upstream: Raw crude oil and natural gas are the primary products. Services include geological surveys, seismic analysis, drilling, well completion, and field operations support. * Midstream/Transmission: The core offering is the transportation service for hydrocarbons via pipelines/tankers and bulk electricity transmission service via the high-voltage grid. Storage services for hydrocarbons are also key. The commodity (oil, gas, electrons) is moved, but the transaction is typically for the service of moving or storing it. Basic processing services (e.g., gas conditioning) may also occur. * Downstream/Generation: This stage produces refined petroleum products (gasoline, diesel, jet fuel, LPG), petrochemicals, processed natural gas, and NGLs. The primary product in the electricity sector is electrical energy (MWh). Generators also provide the service of capacity availability or firm energy obligations crucial for grid reliability. * Distribution/Commercialization: The main exchange involves the local delivery service of electricity and natural gas to end-points. Commercialization involves the retail sale of the energy commodity (kWh of electricity, cubic meters of gas, liters of fuel) bundled with customer services like billing, metering, and support.

Business Models Used

Diverse business models cater to the specific risks, regulations, and market dynamics of each segment: * E&P (Resource Extraction): High-risk, high-reward model focused on finding and lifting hydrocarbons. Revenue depends on produced volumes and volatile global commodity prices. Requires significant upfront capital investment. (Ecopetrol, IOCs, Independents). * Midstream/Transmission (Regulated/Contracted Service): Lower-risk models based on providing essential infrastructure services. * Hydrocarbon Midstream: Often toll-based, charging fees for transport/storage, sometimes under long-term contracts providing stable cash flow. Can be regulated for key national pipelines. (Ecopetrol, specialized pipeline firms). * Electricity Transmission: Regulated Asset Base (RAB) model where revenue is based on approved tariffs covering costs plus a regulated return on investment. Provides very stable, predictable income. (ISA). * Downstream Refining (Margin Capture): Profitability driven by the "crack spread" – the difference between crude oil purchase costs and refined product sales prices, minus operating costs. Exposed to market volatility in both input and output prices. (Ecopetrol). * Electricity Generation (Merchant, Contracted, Capacity): * Merchant: Selling into the volatile spot market (MEM). Higher potential returns but higher risk. * Contracted (PPAs): Selling under long-term contracts with stable prices. Preferred for financing new projects, especially renewables. * Capacity Payments: Receiving regulated payments for being available to generate, ensuring grid reliability. (EPM, Celsia, Tebsa, IPPs). * Distribution (Regulated Utility): Natural monopoly model within designated service areas. Revenue comes from regulated tariffs designed to cover costs and provide a regulated return. Stable but requires continuous investment and adherence to service quality standards. (EPM, Air-e, Afinia, Vanti). * Commercialization (Retail Margin): Buying energy wholesale and selling retail. * Regulated Market: Earns a regulated margin set by CREG. Relatively low risk but capped upside. * Non-Regulated Market: Negotiates prices and terms directly with large consumers. Higher potential margins but requires managing market price risk and competition. * Fuel Retail: Operates service stations, earning margins on fuel sales plus revenue from associated convenience stores/services. (EPM, Air-e, Afinia, Vanti, Terpel, Biomax).

Bottlenecks and Challenges in Transactions

The previously identified bottlenecks directly impact these relationships and models: * Reserve Depletion & Exploration Hurdles (E&P): Directly threatens the viability of the resource extraction model and the long-term supply contracts underpinning midstream and downstream relationships. Uncertainty discourages high-risk exploration investment. * Infrastructure Security/Capacity (Midstream/Transmission): Pipeline disruptions due to theft or attacks impact transport contracts (failure to deliver/receive volumes) and increase operational costs for midstream players. Transmission congestion prevents generators (especially new renewables) from fulfilling PPAs or selling efficiently into the MEM, impacting their revenue models and potentially stranding generation assets. Delays in transmission build-out hinder the integration of renewable projects financed via PPAs. * Distribution Losses: High non-technical losses directly erode the revenue base of distribution companies operating under the regulated utility model, making it harder to recover costs and invest in network improvements, potentially impacting service quality obligations. * Regulatory Uncertainty: Unpredictable changes in tariffs or market rules can undermine the financial assumptions of long-term investments made under regulated (Transmission, Distribution) or contracted (PPAs) business models. Uncertainty can stall negotiations for PPAs or financing for infrastructure. * Social/Environmental Opposition: Delays caused by social license issues increase project costs and disrupt timelines for all models requiring new infrastructure (E&P, Midstream, Transmission, large Generation), impacting investment returns and contractual obligations.

Conclusion

The Colombian energy value chain is a complex ecosystem vital to the nation's economy, characterized by distinct stages for hydrocarbons and electricity, each populated by key players with specific roles and significant scale. Ecopetrol's dominance in hydrocarbons contrasts with a more fragmented electricity sector featuring major players like EPM, ISA, Celsia, and regional distributors. Commercial relationships are multifaceted, involving regulated tariffs for network services (transmission, distribution), market-based pricing (MEM, fuel retail), and long-term contracts (PPAs, gas supply agreements) that aim to balance risk and ensure stability.

However, the sector faces substantial challenges. Ensuring future hydrocarbon supply through successful and responsible exploration, bolstering infrastructure security against physical threats, overcoming critical bottlenecks in electricity transmission to facilitate the energy transition, reducing pervasive distribution losses, navigating regulatory and policy uncertainties, and managing social and environmental expectations are paramount concerns. The successful integration of renewable energy sources hinges on addressing transmission constraints and modernizing the grid.

The business models employed reflect these dynamics, ranging from high-risk E&P ventures and margin-sensitive refining to stable, regulated network operations and contracted generation. The effectiveness of these models is frequently tested by the identified bottlenecks, particularly infrastructure limitations and regulatory hurdles, which can impede transactions and deter investment.

Recommendations for further research could include: * A detailed quantitative analysis of the economic impact of transmission bottlenecks on renewable energy deployment and wholesale market prices. * Comparative studies on the effectiveness of different strategies employed by distribution companies to combat non-technical losses in challenging regions. * An in-depth assessment of the regulatory framework's adaptability to accommodate emerging technologies like battery storage and green hydrogen within the existing market structure. * Scenario analysis on the long-term implications of varying energy transition pathways on Ecopetrol's integrated business model and Colombia's fiscal position.

Addressing the identified challenges through strategic investment, clear and stable regulatory frameworks, and effective stakeholder engagement will be crucial for ensuring a secure, efficient, and sustainable energy future for Colombia.

References

• Energy Analytics Institute (EAI). reporte-4t23-ecopetrol-eng. (2024-03-01). https://energy-analytics-institute.org/reporte-4t23-ecopetrol-eng/
• Macrotrends. Ecopetrol S.A Revenue 2010-2024 | EC. https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/EC/ecopetrol-s.a/revenue
• LaNota.com. Ranking 2024 sector energía eléctrica de Colombia. (2024-12-05). https://lanota.com/ranking/Ranking-sector-energia-electrica-Colombia.php
• LaNota.com. Ranking 2022 sector energía eléctrica de Colombia. (2023-10-18). https://lanota.com/ranking/Ranking-sector-energia-electrica-Colombia-2022.php
• Stock Analysis. Organización Terpel (BVC:TERPEL) Revenue. https://stockanalysis.com/bvc/terpel/revenue/
• GlobalData. Celsia SA ESP Company Profile. https://www.globaldata.com/company-profile/celsia-sa-esp/
• Infobae. Ahora EPM es la segunda después de Ecopetrol: así quedó el ranking de las empresas con mayores ingresos en Colombia. (2024-03-26). https://www.infobae.com/colombia/2024/03/26/ahora-epm-es-la-segunda-despues-de-ecopetrol-asi-quedo-el-ranking-de-las-empresas-con-mayores-ingresos-en-colombia/
• Las2orillas.co. Los 4 grandes que más han ganado con la energía eléctrica en Colombia. (2022-09-19). https://www.las2orillas.co/los-4-grandes-que-mas-han-ganado-con-la-energia-electrica-en-colombia/
• Stock Analysis. Organización Terpel S.A. (BVC:TERPEL) Stock Price & Overview. https://stockanalysis.com/bvc/terpel/
• ColombiaOne.com. Top Ten Largest Companies in Colombia. (2024-01-20). https://colombiaone.com/top-ten-largest-companies-in-colombia/
• Investing.com. Celsia SA (BVC:CELSIA) Revenue. https://www.investing.com/equities/celsia-revenue