Energy in Colombia Customer Challenges and Pains Analysis¶

Challenges and Pains faced by Customers¶

Based on the analysis of the provided reports on the Colombian energy value chain, final customers, encompassing both Business-to-Consumer (B2C) and Business-to-Business (B2B) segments, face several significant challenges and pains. These issues stem from various points in the value chain, impacting the cost, reliability, and availability of energy.

A primary pain point for customers, particularly residential users and small commercial entities in the regulated market, is the high cost of energy, leading to inflated tariffs. This is directly exacerbated by significant technical and non-technical distribution losses, especially notable in regions like the Caribbean coast served by Air-e and Afinia. These losses increase the overall cost of energy that paying customers must cover through their regulated tariffs. Furthermore, regulatory complexities and the challenge of balancing affordable tariffs with the need for utilities to recover costs and invest also contribute to tariff levels.

Unreliable service and supply disruptions represent another major challenge. While not explicitly detailed as a direct customer complaint in the provided text, the bottlenecks identified in the value chain directly imply this pain. Infrastructure security risks, such as illegal tapping and sabotage in hydrocarbon pipelines, can lead to fuel supply disruptions. More critically for electricity consumers, limitations and delays in expanding the transmission grid can hinder the stable flow of power from generation sources to demand centers, potentially leading to voltage issues, outages, or load shedding. Aging or inefficient distribution networks, linked to technical losses, can also result in localized service interruptions and unreliable power quality for customers.

The lack of long-term certainty regarding energy supply and affordability is an underlying concern derived from challenges at the upstream stages and infrastructure development. Declining hydrocarbon reserves pose a potential future risk to the consistent availability and pricing of natural gas and liquid fuels. Delays in the development of new generation capacity (including renewables) and associated transmission infrastructure, often caused by permitting issues, social opposition, or difficulties accessing capital, can threaten future electricity supply adequacy and potentially drive up costs. This uncertainty makes long-term energy planning difficult for large industrial and commercial users and can lead to price volatility.

Customers, particularly those in the regulated market (residential and small commercial), experience limited options and flexibility in their energy procurement. Their tariffs and service conditions are determined by regulatory frameworks, offering little room for negotiation or customization compared to large commercial and industrial users in the non-regulated market who can negotiate tailored contracts and Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs). While large customers have more options, they still face pains related to market price risk if not managed effectively and challenges in securing long-term contracts under conditions of regulatory or supply uncertainty.

Finally, while less direct, the impacts from social and environmental conflicts on energy projects can ultimately translate into pains for customers. Delays or cancellations of necessary infrastructure (E&P, pipelines, transmission lines, power plants) due to community opposition or environmental hurdles can lead to project cost increases, which may eventually be reflected in energy prices, or contribute to supply constraints and reduced reliability.

Here is a prioritized table of the main challenges and pains faced by customers:

Priority	Challenge/Pain	Description	Primarily Impacts
1	High Energy Costs / Inflated Tariffs	Costs increased by factors like distribution losses, regulatory complexities, and potential inefficiencies upstream/midstream.	Regulated B2C, Small Commercial B2B
2	Unreliable Service / Supply Disruptions	Interruption or instability of energy supply due to infrastructure issues, security risks, or grid constraints.	All B2C and B2B (critical for Industrial)
3	Lack of Long-Term Supply Certainty and Affordability	Uncertainty about future availability and cost of energy due to resource depletion, delayed projects, and investment challenges.	All B2C and B2B
4	Limited Options and Flexibility	Restricted ability for regulated customers to choose suppliers or negotiate terms; challenges for large users in securing ideal contracts.	Regulated B2C, Small Commercial B2B; Large B2B
5	Impacts from Social and Environmental Conflicts	Project delays/costs due to community/environmental opposition, indirectly affecting supply and costs.	All B2C and B2B (indirect)

Correlation with Value Chain¶

The challenges and pains faced by customers in the Colombian energy sector are directly correlated with specific steps and bottlenecks identified in the value chain analysis:

High Energy Costs / Inflated Tariffs: This pain is most strongly correlated with the Distribution and Commercialization stages. High technical and non-technical losses in the distribution networks directly increase the cost base that commercialization companies must recover through tariffs, particularly in the regulated market. Regulatory decisions on tariff setting at the commercialization stage also determine the final price paid by regulated customers. Indirectly, bottlenecks in Generation and Transmission that prevent the integration of lower-cost energy sources can also impact the wholesale energy price component within customer tariffs.
Unreliable Service / Supply Disruptions: This pain is correlated with the physical infrastructure segments of the value chain: Midstream (Hydrocarbons), Transmission (Electricity), and Distribution (Electricity and Gas). Security issues affecting hydrocarbon pipelines can disrupt the flow of fuels and natural gas. Limitations and delays in electricity transmission infrastructure development directly impact the ability to move power reliably across the grid, potentially leading to disruptions. The condition and efficiency of the local distribution networks also directly influence the reliability of supply to final customer premises.
Lack of Long-Term Supply Certainty and Affordability: This pain is linked to the upstream stages and overall infrastructure development. Declining hydrocarbon reserves at the Exploration & Production stage raise concerns about future supply availability. Delays in investing in and constructing new Generation plants and expanding the Transmission grid to connect them impact the long-term adequacy of electricity supply. Challenges related to Access to Capital and Regulatory Uncertainty can hinder necessary investments across the entire value chain, affecting long-term supply and cost predictability.
Limited Options and Flexibility: This pain is primarily correlated with the structure of the Commercialization stage and the governing regulatory framework. The distinction between the regulated and non-regulated markets, as defined by regulation, determines the level of choice and negotiation power available to different customer segments.
Impacts from Social and Environmental Conflicts: This pain, while indirect, affects project development across multiple value chain stages, including Exploration & Production (new wells), Midstream (pipelines), Transmission (lines), and Generation (power plants). Delays or increased costs at any of these stages can eventually impact the cost and reliability of energy delivered to the customer.

In essence, the challenges faced by the entities operating within each segment of the energy value chain translate directly into pains experienced by the final customers, highlighting the interconnected nature of the industry from resource extraction to final consumption.

References¶

Energy Analytics Institute (EAI). reporte-4t23-ecopetrol-eng. (2024-03-01). https://energy-analytics-institute.org/reporte-4t23-ecopetrol-eng/
Macrotrends. Ecopetrol S.A Revenue 2010-2024 | EC. https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/EC/ecopetrol-s.a/revenue
LaNota.com. Ranking 2024 sector energía eléctrica de Colombia. (2024-12-05). https://lanota.com/ranking/Ranking-sector-energia-electrica-Colombia.php
LaNota.com. Ranking 2022 sector energía eléctrica de Colombia. (2023-10-18). https://lanota.com/ranking/Ranking-sector-energia-electrica-Colombia-2022.php
Stock Analysis. Organización Terpel (BVC:TERPEL) Revenue. https://stockanalysis.com/bvc/terpel/revenue/
GlobalData. Celsia SA ESP Company Profile. https://www.globaldata.com/company-profile/celsia-sa-esp/
Infobae. Ahora EPM es la segunda después de Ecopetrol: así quedó el ranking de las empresas con mayores ingresos en Colombia. (2024-03-26). https://www.infobae.com/colombia/2024/03/26/ahora-epm-es-la-segunda-despues-de-ecopetrol-asi-quedo-el-ranking-de-las-empresas-con-mayores-ingresos-en-colombia/
Las2orillas.co. Los 4 grandes que más han ganado con la energía eléctrica en Colombia. (2022-09-19). https://www.las2orillas.co/los-4-grandes-que-mas-han-ganado-con-la-energia-electrica-en-colombia/
Stock Analysis. Organización Terpel S.A. (BVC:TERPEL) Stock Price & Overview. https://stockanalysis.com/bvc/terpel/
ColombiaOne.com. Top Ten Largest Companies in Colombia. (2024-01-20). https://colombiaone.com/top-ten-largest-companies-in-colombia/
Investing.com. Celsia SA (BVC:CELSIA) Revenue. https://www.investing.com/equities/celsia-revenue