Skip to content

Banking in Mexico Porter's Six Forces Analysis

This report analyzes the competitive landscape of the Mexican banking industry using Porter's Six Forces framework, drawing insights from the provided value chain analysis and market player information. The framework considers the intensity of rivalry among existing competitors, the threat of new entrants, the bargaining power of buyers (customers), the bargaining power of suppliers, the threat of substitute products or services, and the influence of complementors.

Threat of New Entrants

The threat of new entrants in the Mexican banking sector is moderate but increasing, largely driven by the rise of financial technology (fintech) companies. Historically, the high capital requirements, stringent regulatory environment overseen by the CNBV, and the need for extensive physical infrastructure like branch networks and ATMs have acted as significant barriers to entry for traditional banks. The market is characterized by high concentration, with the top seven banks holding approximately 80% of total assets, further limiting the space for new large-scale competitors.

However, the landscape is changing rapidly due to the Fintech Law (2018), which was specifically aimed at fostering innovation and competition. This regulatory framework has facilitated the entry and growth of numerous fintech companies, with Mexico boasting one of the largest fintech ecosystems in Latin America, comprising approximately 773 local and 217 foreign firms in early 2024. These fintechs, including digital lenders like Konfío and neobanks such as Albo, Klar, Hey Banco, NuBank, and Revolut, often enter specific niches like payments, consumer lending, or digital wallets, bypassing some traditional barriers. The launch of digital-only banks by established players like Banorte (Bíneo) and Santander (Openbank) also signifies a shift towards easier digital entry points, although these are from existing players. Despite regulatory efforts, navigating the complex implementation of the Fintech Law and related secondary regulations (e.g., Open Banking rules) can still pose challenges for new players, and the dominance of incumbents presents a competitive hurdle.

Bargaining Power of Buyers (Customers)

The bargaining power of customers in the Mexican banking sector is currently moderate but is expected to increase with digital transformation and open banking initiatives. The high concentration among the top banks traditionally limits the power of individual retail customers, as they have fewer major institutions to choose from for core banking services. This can lead to potentially higher fees or less favorable terms in certain product areas. Corporate and SME clients, however, often possess greater bargaining power due to their larger transaction volumes and more complex financial needs, allowing them to negotiate terms and access tailored services.

The emergence of fintech companies and digital banks is empowering consumers by offering alternative choices, often with lower fees, more convenient digital experiences, and products tailored to specific needs, including those of underserved segments. Digital payment systems like SPEI and DiMo, promoted by Banxico, also increase customer convenience and choice in transactions. The presence of CONDUSEF, the consumer protection agency, also contributes to safeguarding customer rights and providing recourse. The full implementation of Open Banking regulations is anticipated to further increase customer power by enabling them to easily share their financial data and access a wider range of services from different providers, fostering greater competition and potentially leading to better terms and services.

Bargaining Power of Suppliers

The bargaining power of suppliers in the Mexican banking value chain varies depending on the type of supplier.

  • Fund Providers (Depositors and Wholesale Markets): Individual depositors, while numerous, generally have limited individual bargaining power, although collective action or the availability of attractive alternative savings/investment options (including those from fintechs) can influence deposit rates offered by banks. Providers of wholesale funding, such as large institutional investors and other financial institutions, possess significant bargaining power, particularly for large funding rounds or complex financial instruments, influencing the cost of capital for banks.
  • Technology Vendors: As banking becomes increasingly reliant on technology and digital infrastructure, the power of specialized technology vendors and cloud service providers is significant. Banks depend on these suppliers for core banking systems, cybersecurity solutions, and digital platform development, giving these vendors leverage in pricing and service terms.
  • Correspondent Banking Agents: Networks like OXXO, acting as banking correspondents, hold considerable bargaining power due to their extensive reach and crucial role in providing basic financial services to a broad population, especially in areas with limited bank branches. Their widespread presence makes them valuable partners for banks seeking to expand financial inclusion and facilitate cash-based transactions.

Threat of Substitute Products or Services

The threat of substitute products and services in the Mexican financial landscape is substantial and evolving, driven by technological advancements and the persistence of informal financial mechanisms.

  • Cash: Despite the growth of digital payments, a significant portion of transactions in Mexico are still conducted in cash. Cash remains a primary substitute for electronic payment methods, particularly for lower-value transactions and among the financially excluded population.
  • Informal Financial Systems: For a large segment of the population, particularly the 40% who are financially excluded, informal financial mechanisms like "tandas" (rotating savings and credit associations) and informal lenders serve as direct substitutes for formal banking products like savings accounts and loans.
  • Fintech Solutions: Fintech companies offer various services that act as substitutes for traditional banking products. Digital wallets can substitute for bank accounts for payments, online lending platforms offer an alternative to bank loans (especially for SMEs and individuals with limited credit history), and specialized investment platforms can substitute for traditional brokerage services. Spin by OXXO, leveraging its retail network, provides digital wallet services that substitute for basic bank accounts and payment functionalities.
  • Non-Bank Financial Institutions: Entities like SOFOMs (Sociedades Financieras de Objeto Múltiple) provide lending and other financial services that substitute for those offered by traditional banks, particularly in niche markets.

Intensity of Rivalry

The intensity of rivalry in the Mexican banking sector is high and increasing. While the market is dominated by a few large players (the G-7 banks holding ~80% of assets), competition exists across various dimensions.

  • Competition Among Incumbents: The major banks, including BBVA México, Banorte, and Santander México, compete intensely for market share in key segments like consumer loans, mortgages, and deposits. This rivalry manifests in differentiated product offerings, pricing strategies, and efforts to enhance customer experience through digital channels. The launch of digital banks by incumbents (Bíneo by Banorte, Openbank by Santander) indicates direct competition for the digitally-savvy customer segment and rivalry with neobanks.
  • Competition from Fintechs: The rapid growth and innovation within the fintech sector significantly increases rivalry, particularly in payments and lending. Fintechs compete on speed, convenience, and often lower costs, forcing incumbents to accelerate their own digital transformation to remain competitive.
  • Competition on Services and Technology: Beyond traditional price competition, rivalry is strong in the area of digital service delivery, mobile banking functionality, and the adoption of new technologies to improve efficiency and customer engagement.

Influence of Complementors

Complementors play a vital role in shaping the Mexican banking industry by enhancing the value proposition of banking services.

  • Regulators (Banxico, CNBV, CONDUSEF, UIF): These bodies are critical complementors, providing the necessary regulatory framework and oversight that ensures the stability, integrity, and trustworthiness of the financial system. Banxico, as the central bank, operates key payment systems like SPEI and DiMo, which are essential infrastructure for all participants in the payments value chain. CONDUSEF complements the industry by promoting consumer confidence and providing a mechanism for dispute resolution. The UIF complements efforts to combat financial crime. While compliance can be burdensome, the regulatory environment is fundamental to the industry's operation and public trust.
  • Technology Providers: Companies providing core banking software, cybersecurity solutions, cloud infrastructure, and data analytics tools are crucial complementors. Their offerings enable banks to operate efficiently, innovate, and deliver digital services effectively. The capabilities of these technology partners directly enhance the services banks can provide to their customers.
  • Correspondent Banking Networks (e.g., OXXO): These networks complement the physical infrastructure of banks, extending their reach and making basic financial services more accessible to a wider population. They enhance the value of banking services by providing convenient points for cash transactions and payments, particularly in underserved areas.
  • Payment Networks (Visa, Mastercard, etc.): These global networks are essential complementors for card-based payments, providing the infrastructure for authorization, clearing, and settlement of transactions.

References

  • Banking & Finance 2024 - Mexico | Global Practice Guides - Chambers and Partners. https://chambers.com/law-areas/banking-finance-mexico-global-practice-guide
  • Banking Laws and Regulations 2025 | Mexico - Global Legal Insights. https://www.globallegalinsights.com/practice-areas/banking-and-finance-laws-and-regulations/mexico
  • Mexico - Digital Economy - International Trade Administration. https://www.trade.gov/country-commercial-guides/mexico-digital-economy
  • Mexico in Focus: Open Banking and Financial Inclusion. https://fair.org/mexico-in-focus-open-banking-and-financial-inclusion/
  • Mexico: 2024 analysis of payments and ecommerce trends. https://thepaypers.com/reports/payment-methods/mexico-2024-analysis-of-payments-and-ecommerce-trends--1294554
  • The Truth About Mexico's Financial Exclusion—And How Fintech Is Fixing It. https://novobanking.com/blog/fintech/financial-exclusion-mexico-fintech/
  • Ensuring financial inclusion in Mexico by 2024 - FAIR Center. https://fair.org/financial-inclusion-mexico-2024/
  • The Mexican banks leading the market - Frecuencia Money. https://frecuenciamoney.com/bancos-mexicanos-lideres-mercado/
  • National Survey of Financial Inclusion (ENIF) 2024 - Inegi. https://www.inegi.org.mx/programas/enif/2024/default.html (Note: Link mentions 2024, but text refers to 2023 survey results, latest available seem to be 2021 referenced in other sources. Using 2023/40% figure as per context.)
  • Banking Regulation in Mexico: Overview. https://content.next.westlaw.com/practical-law/document/Ie0114b114c1b11e9964f8b36bbf2d772/Banking-Regulation-in-Mexico-Overview
  • Banorte Mints First Domestic Digital Bank In Mexico - Global Finance Magazine. https://www.gfmag.com/daily-news/banorte-mints-first-domestic-digital-bank-mexico
  • Digital Payments Growth and Transformation in Latin America - BofA Securities. https://ml.bofasecurities.com/content/dam/ml/articles/pdf/LATAM_Digital_Payments_and_Transformation_in_Latin_America.pdf
  • Mexico's Fintech Revolution: LATAM's Financial Hub. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/mexicos-fintech-revolution-latams-financial-hub-felipe-santiago/
  • How Banks in Mexico can use Advanced PFM to Grow Market Share - Personetics. https://personetics.com/resource/how-banks-in-mexico-can-use-advanced-pfm-to-grow-market-share/
  • The changing nature of the financial system in Mexico: the allocation of finance, long-term growth and policy measures. https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/sites/d707c82f-en/index.html?itemId=/content/component/d707c82f-en
  • List of Banks in Mexico - Global Banking | Finance | Review. https://www.globalbankingandfinance.com/banking-in-mexico/list-of-banks-in-mexico/
  • Latam Insights: Challenges and Opportunities in Mexico's Power Sector | Post - Scotiabank. https://perspectivesandinsights.scotiabank.com/en/2023/latam-insights-challenges-and-opportunities-in-mexicos-power-sector/
  • Mexico: 2024 analysis of payments and ecommerce trends - ThePaypers. https://thepaypers.com/reports/payment-methods/mexico-2024-analysis-of-payments-and-ecommerce-trends--1294554
  • Mexico: 2024 Article IV Consultation and Review Under the Flexible Credit Line Arrangement-Press Release; Staff Report - Banco de México. https://www.banxico.org.mx/publicaciones-y-prensa/informes-anuales/%7B2024468A-9370-F35E-D97B-5027E1424270%7D.pdf
  • Commercial Banking in Mexico - HR Ratings. https://www.hrratings.com/pdf/calificaciones/Comentarios/Comentarios%20Banca%20Comercial%20en%20M%C3%A9xico%20-%20Jun%202024.pdf
  • Mexico 2025: Challenges Worsen - Latinvex. https://latinvex.com/mexico-2025-challenges-worsen/
  • Latin America's 30 largest banks by assets, 2024 | S&P Global. https://www.spglobal.com/marketintelligence/en/news-insights/latest-news-headlines/latin-america-s-30-largest-banks-by-assets-2024-82005313
  • Mexico Total Deposits, 1998 – 2025 | CEIC Data. https://www.ceicdata.com/en/indicator/mexico/total-deposits
  • Mexico's Banking Sector Ends 2024 with Low Delinquency. https://www.centralamericadata.com/en/article/home/Mexicos_Banking_Sector_Ends_2024_with_Low_Delinquency
  • Fintech 2025 - Mexico | Global Practice Guides - Chambers and Partners. https://chambers.com/law-areas/fintech-mexico-global-practice-guide
  • Banxico, central bank, Banco de México. https://www.banxico.org.mx/
  • Openbank debuts in Mexico with fully digital proposition, no fees and competitive rates of return - Banco Santander. https://www.santander.com/en/press-room/press-releases/2024/01/openbank-debuts-in-mexico-with-fully-digital-proposition
  • Plan México: Better late than never | BBVA Research. https://www.bbvaresearch.com/en/publicaciones/plan-mexico-better-late-than-never/
  • Strong peso, stubborn inflation cloud Mexico's 2024 growth prospects - Dallasfed.org. https://www.dallasfed.org/research/latin-america/2024/la2403
  • FINNOVISTA FINTECH RADAR MÉXICO - Finnosummit. https://www.finnosummit.com/es/recursos/descarga-el-finnovista-fintech-radar-mexico/
  • Openbank launches in Mexico - Banco Santander. https://www.santander.com/en/press-room/press-releases/2024/01/openbank-debuts-in-mexico-with-fully-digital-proposition
  • World's Best Investment Banks 2025: Debt - Global Finance Magazine. https://www.gfmag.com/magazine/march-2024/worlds-best-investment-banks-2025-debt